Tolkkinen: For Minnesota hunters, a run to get butter for breakfast lasted 36 hours, and over a decade

The incident in the northwest corner of the state sparked a tradition and bonding that goes beyond hunting.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
November 19, 2025 at 5:07PM
Four members of a northwestern Minnesota deer hunting camp make one of their legendary Butter Runs to Millerville Creamery in west-central Minnesota. They are, from left, Jeff Kroll, Mike "G Bass" Goroski and Ken Johnson of Argyle, and Jeremy Erickson of Otter Tail County. (Provided)

One morning, about a generation ago (or possibly only a dozen years; memories vary) a group of hunters left deer camp in northwestern Minnesota to buy butter for breakfast.

A group of them crowded into an old Suburban while another half-dozen remained at camp, which was a decommissioned refrigerated semitrailer fitted with bunk beds.

The mission was simple. Go get butter. Come back, finish making eggs or pancakes or whatever.

They came back, all right — more than a day later, with the butter. What should have been a half-hour run to the grocery store ended up in a 36-hour (more or less) meandering hopscotch across hunting country, visiting deer camps throughout the region until they found themselves near the Canadian border.

“It was like, ‘Oh, let’s go over to so-and-so’s deer camp and say hi,’ and then when we were that far, we’re like, ‘Well, we should run over to this other one and say hi,’” recalled Jeff Kroll, a graphic designer from Argyle. “And, well, you know, one thing led to another, and before you know it, we were by the Canadian border, and it was a day later before we came home.”

It was to go down in deer camp annals as the inaugural Butter Run World Tour, one of those cherished hunting traditions as important, or even more so, than the hunt itself.

This was before cellphones were as ubiquitous or as reliable as they are now in Minnesota’s northwest corner. But as time passed without word, hunters remaining at camp didn’t worry, said Mike Dufault, who was there. In fact, come evening, they did a little disappearing of their own, off to enjoy what local taverns had to offer.

The Butter Run has remained a running joke over the years. Want to visit someone else’s camp? That’s a Butter Run. Running some errands? That’s a Butter Run, too. By the way, please come back.

Kroll printed up T-shirts with the Butter Run World Tour logo on the front and a list of places the tour has gone, or wishes to go, or just thought would be cool to have on the shirt. Along with Kittson and Hubbard counties, the list includes Mesopotamia; Greasy Corner, Ark.; Buttzville, N.J.; and Zigzag, Ore. St. Clair Shores, Mich., a thousand miles away, made the list because it is home to the Butter Run Saloon. It’s too lengthy a trip for deer camp, but they hope to go in the offseason.

The back of the Butter Run Global Tour includes all the places the Butter Runners from Argyle, Minn., have stopped — or wish they could stop. (Provided)

Their camp isn’t far from the Red River, and it attracts a passel of guys who went to school together in Argyle or met at college, their kids and grandkids, and sometimes wives and daughters. Most of them farm sugar beets or small grains, and Minnesota’s rifle season for deer hunting often comes right after harvest, giving them a chance to let off a little steam.

And while the older generation enjoys coaching the kids on getting a deer, the camp is as much about having fun as it is about hunting.

“We’re basically a bunch of 12-year-old boys,” Dufault said. He might have missed out on the inaugural run, but he has gone on his own over the years.

Every deer camp has its own culture, and the Butter Runs have become part of theirs. Other cultural activities may or may not have included swiping a rug from a local establishment to decorate the semitrailer. (It was returned after the bar called the mom of one of the guys.)

Another misdeed may or may not have involved a massive popcorn fight at yet another local establishment during which someone absconded with a Dale Earnhardt Jr. cutout.

“There may be a couple of — what do we call them — souvenirs in the hunting shack that we got over the years,” Dufault said.

Twenty years later — or 10, or 12, depending on whose memory we’re consulting — the Butter Run tour finally made a stop worthy of its name, at a real creamery that makes butter.

They were hunting near Dalton, not far from where we live, and made a side trip to the Millerville Creamery, a little operation that still regularly churns out hand-wrapped butter. A draw for politicians and journalists, the creamery is one of the last in Minnesota to make small batches of butter. It’s a big deal in Millerville, population about 100, which has Millerville Butter Day in August, complete with a butter-carving contest.

Jody Dahlseid, the creamery’s general manager of retail, butter and branding, met the four Butter Runners who stopped by to purchase butter and butter merch. They regaled her with their love for all things butter and posed for a photo for the creamery’s Facebook page.

To Dahlseid, the butter quest might as well end right in Millerville.

“You can stop looking! You found the best stuff,” she said.

But the Argyle Butter Runners are already planning ahead. One of their reasons for speaking to me is that they have expansion plans.

They haven’t yet visited any camps in the Arrowhead. It’s quite a distance, but they wouldn’t necessarily turn down an invitation to visit deer camps there. They can always add a few destinations to the backs of their shirts.

about the writer

about the writer

Karen Tolkkinen

Columnist

Karen Tolkkinen is a columnist for the Minnesota Star Tribune, focused on the issues and people of greater Minnesota.

See Moreicon

More from Greater Minnesota

See More
card image
Courtesy of Tayla Michelle Henry

The runaway dumpster skated away from a Moorhead bar twice during the recent winter storm.

card image
card image