RandBall: Vikings could be headed for an interesting QB conundrum

Carson Wentz will get at least one more start for the Vikings. What if he plays well and they keep winning? Michael Rand looks at that in today’s 10 things to know.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
September 22, 2025 at 6:41PM
Vikings quarterback Carson Wentz (11) celebrates with Justin Jefferson after throwing a touchdown pass to Josh Oliver (84) in the first quarter Sunday against the Bengals. (Carlos Gonzalez/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

The long-term future of the quarterback position for the Vikings is not a mystery.

It’s J.J. McCarthy, the No. 10 pick in the 2024 draft, the guy who started the first two games of this season before being temporarily shelved by a sprained ankle and the player to whom they have affixed Super Bowl dreams.

The present situation is not a mystery, either. Veteran Carson Wentz stepped in Sunday for McCarthy and efficiently played a “point guard” version of the position, according to head coach Kevin O’Connell. Wentz generally made good and quick decisions while getting the ball in the hands of the Vikings’ playmakers in a 48-10 win over Cincinnati.

Where things could get murky, though, is in the near future. Patrick Reusse and I talked about that on Monday’s Daily Delivery podcast, but let’s play out some scenarios here as well at the start of today’s 10 things to know:

  • CBS’s Tracy Wolfson reported that the expectation is that Wentz not only plays next week against the Steelers but also gets the second overseas game against the Browns. That could change based on McCarthy’s healing process, but what if Wentz does indeed play both of those games ... and plays well ... and the Vikings win both to go to 4-1. There’s a bye week after that, giving McCarthy plenty of time to get healthy. What do you do at QB then? “I keep playing Carson Wentz,” Reusse said. “And guess what? So will they.”
    • I’m not sure I fully buy into that because of everything the Vikings have invested in McCarthy and their keen interest in continuing his development, but it would be hard to go away from Wentz at that point. And when Vikings coach Kevin O’Connell was asked if McCarthy would resume his place on the field when he’s healthy, the coach gave a long response that included this: “It doesn’t require an answer on that question today.”
      • There’s an in-between possibility where the Vikings continue winning but Wentz is exceedingly mediocre (or worse), which would make it far easier to turn things back to McCarthy when he’s healthy. Imagine, say, a couple of 13-10 wins aided mostly by the defense in these next two weeks.
        • And of course, if the Vikings drop any games during Wentz’s stint as starter, it would limit any conundrum.
          • Complicating everything is the Vikings’ post-bye schedule. It’s the hardest stretch of the season: vs. the Eagles, at the Chargers, at the Lions and vs. the Ravens. Those opponents will stress the Vikings defense in ways it won’t be challenged before the bye, and they will need to score points to keep up. It will be a difficult stretch for either Wentz or McCarthy, the latter of whom must get healthy before any decisions are made. We’ll see how things play out leading up to it.
            • Reusse and I talked plenty about the Lynx’s 82-69 win over Phoenix in Game 1 of the WNBA semifinals Sunday. It was another master class in second-half poise and execution by Cheryl Reeve’s team. Here is a postgame Lynx-specific podcast that went up on Sunday after the game:
              about the writer

              about the writer

              Michael Rand

              Columnist / Reporter

              Michael Rand is the Minnesota Star Tribune's Digital Sports Senior Writer and host/creator of the Daily Delivery podcast. In 25 years covering Minnesota sports at the Minnesota Star Tribune, he has seen just about everything (except, of course, a Vikings Super Bowl).

              See Moreicon

              More from Sports

              See More
              card image
              Jeff McIntosh/The Canadian Press

              The Flames scored two goals less than three minutes apart early in the third to take control in the Wild’s first regulation loss in nearly a month.

              card image
              card image