Analysis: Koi Perich’s fourth-quarter blunder part of Gophers football’s bigger issues

After starting the season with a pair of victories with clean play, a very uncharacteristic Gophers team showed up in the Bay Area in a 27-14 loss at Cal.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
September 14, 2025 at 6:16PM
From the eight penalties for 85 yards to dropped passes by wide receivers and missed assignments by linemen, the Gophers played sloppily in Saturday's loss to Cal. (Jose Carlos Fajardo/The Associated Press)

BERKELEY, CALIF. – Last fall, Koi Perich introduced himself to the college football world in grand fashion. The true freshman from Esko, Minn., had famously turned down mighty Ohio State the previous winter and stayed with his home-state Gophers in a major recruiting win for Minnesota coach P.J. Fleck.

On the field, Perich immediately showed a flair for the dramatic.

He put the exclamation point on the Gophers’ home victory over Southern California with an end zone interception, which led to students storming the field and carrying him off on their shoulders. The next game, he was at it again, sealing a victory at UCLA with the second of his two interceptions as roughly 16,000 Gophers fans celebrated at the Rose Bowl.

That brings us to Saturday night at California Memorial Stadium, where it became apparent that the 2025 script is playing out differently for the Gophers and Perich.

In a back-and-forth battle in which the Gophers trailed early but rallied to take a third-quarter lead over Cal, Perich played a key role in an episode that led to the Golden Bears securing a closer-than-the-score-looks 27-14 victory.

Cal remained ahead 17-14 after the Gophers’ Brady Denaburg missed a 51-yard field-goal attempt — which came after an unsuccessful run call on third-and-7. On the ensuing possession, the Minnesota defense forced the Golden Bears to punt from their 47-yard line.

Perich, a second-team All-American by the Sporting News last year, was back to field the punt from Michael Kern. The ball took a sideways bounce, and Perich adjusted to track it. On a second bounce, the football shifted back and caromed toward Perich. The ball hit off Perich’s left foot, and Cal’s Aiden Manutai recovered the muffed punt return at the Minnesota 8-yard line. Three plays later, Bears quarterback Jaron-Keawe Sagapolutele hit wide receiver Jordan King for a 2-yard touchdown pass and 24-14 lead that became the decisive points.

It was a mixed bag Saturday night.

ADVERTISEMENT

Perich made a fair catch at the 3-yard line rather than let the ball bounce into the end zone. He also had a 19-yard reception, but he also took a sack on a trick play in which he was preparing to throw an option pass.

Fleck empathized with his star player, who has taken on offensive duties this season to go along with his roles at safety and on special teams.

“All great players go through adversity,” Fleck said. “This is probably his first piece of adversity in the 15 months he’s been here. Adversity strengthens you if you use it properly. You swallow the pill of adversity, and you take accountability and responsibility for it, and we all do it. It’s going to make you better.”

This is not to say Perich was the reason the Gophers lost.

He had a rough night, but there was plenty of blame to spread around — from the eight penalties for 85 yards to dropped passes by wide receivers to missed assignments by linemen.

“We were casual tonight,” quarterback Drake Lindsey said, “and I’ve gotta be a better leader and get us in the right spots.”

Linebacker Maverick Baranowski believes Perich responded quickly and turned the page.

“Stuff like that’s going to happen in football. Mistakes are going to happen,” Baranowski said. “He did a good job responding. … At the end of the day, that’s what we preach in this culture. And I thought he did a great job at that."

Fleck sees Perich’s tough night as an aberration.

“He does so many great things, and he does them so naturally, and he’s been coached really hard by a lot of different people,” Fleck said. “… Again, it’s not Koi’s fault. It’s my fault, but it’s our team’s responsibility to win football games — not Koi’s, not Drake’s, not Maverick’s. We’re a team, and we didn’t do enough on special teams, offense and defense to win that football game."

about the writer

about the writer

Randy Johnson

College football reporter

Randy Johnson covers University of Minnesota football and college football for the Minnesota Star Tribune, along with Gophers hockey and the Wild.

See Moreicon

More from Gophers

See More
card image
Samantha Hollingshead/Gophers athletics

Luca Di Pasquo made 32 saves and the Gophers began their final series of 2025 with a conference road victory.

card image
card image