Going old-school: Thinking outside of the box for NFL MVP candidates

A Bears guard? A Packers pass rusher? What about the 49ers’ Christian McCaffrey? Here are some players who deserve consideration to be the first non-QB to win MVP since Adrian Peterson in 2012.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
December 5, 2025 at 4:19PM
Green Bay Packers defensive end Micah Parsons ranks third in the NFL in sacks with 12.5 and third in pressures with 67. (David Dermer/The Associated Press)

Nothing is more inside-the-box than voting for NFL Most Valuable Quarterb …, er, Player.

Currently, the race that seems to exclude anyone who doesn’t play quarterback is between the Patriots’ Drake Maye and the sentimental favorite, 37-year-old Matthew Stafford of the Rams.

Since a quarterback has won every MVP since Vikings running back Adrian Peterson won it in 2012, it seems silly to suggest a more inclusive field to consider. But, what the heck, let’s give it a shot with these four fellas:

  • Bears guard Joe Thuney. Like the Vikings, the Bears rebuilt the entirety of their interior offensive line. Unlike the Vikings, it worked. Ask Philly how well Thuney and his inside mates did while pounding out 281 yards and two TDs on 47 carries (6.0 yards per carry) last week. A four-time Super Bowl champion with the Patriots and Chiefs, no player has had a bigger impact on the turnaround in Chicago than Thuney, a soon-to-be three-time first-team All-Pro.
    • Seahawks receiver Jaxon Smith-Njigba. A kicker has won an MVP, but a receiver never has, believe it or not. It’s only Week 14, and JSN already has a franchise-record and league-leading 1,336 yards receiving on a nine-win team. He’s averaging 16.3 yards per catch, has a 123.6 rating when targeted and has only three drops in 111 targets.
      • Packers do-it-all superstar Micah Parsons. A year ago, the Packers were the little brothers to the good teams in the NFC North. Now they’re feared. Why? Because Jerry Jones doesn’t appreciate defense, and he made life miserable for the Bears, Lions and Vikings by trading Parsons to the Packers in his prime. Parsons ranks third in sacks with 12.5, third in pressures (67) and probably first in messing up offensive rhythm in general. A defensive player has won MVP only twice (Alan Page in 1971 and Lawrence Taylor in 1986), and you can bet your kid’s future it will never happen again.
        • 49ers running back Christian McCaffrey. Unlike the first three, this one at least has a chance of being seriously considered. If it’s not, then why the heck not? McCaffrey is the primary reason the beat-up 49ers are 9-4. He’s the No. 1 reason the 49ers went 5-3 without franchise quarterback Brock Purdy. He’s why the 49ers control games and keep us from even talking about the fact Nick Bosa suffered a season-ending injury 10 games ago. McCaffrey has a league-leading 1,655 yards from scrimmage. He is only 151 yards rushing and 194 yards receiving from posting 1,000 yards in each. And he’s the only player with at least five touchdowns rushing (8) and receiving (5).

          Sorry, QBs, but you aren’t the only guys on the field.

          Stat of the week

          26 and 7. These two numbers explain why the Vikings are looking up at the Bears (9-3) and Packers (8-3-1), who play for the NFC North lead at Lambeau Field on Sunday afternoon. The first number is the Bears’ league-leading number of takeaways. The second number is the Packers’ league-low number of giveaways. Meanwhile, the Vikings are last in turnover differential (minus-15).

          Did you know?

          The AFC South-leading showdown between the Colts (8-4) and host Jaguars (8-4) features a Colts run game that leads the league in average per carry (5.1) and a Jaguars run defense that allows a league-low 82.4 yards per game. Indy scores a league-leading 29.8 points per game while the Jags are the only AFC team to have allowed 10 or fewer points four times. These two teams meet twice in the next four weeks.

          Steelers head coach Mike Tomlin faces a critical game against the Ravens as Pittsburgh pursues its third straight playoff berth. (Gene J. Puskar/The Associated Press)

          AFC North thought of the week

          Overshadowed by the “Fire Tomlin!” chants in Pittsburgh is a tight AFC North race that could result in Mike Tomlin leading the Steelers to a third straight playoff berth since Ben Roethlisberger retired four years ago. The Steelers (6-6) face the Ravens (6-6) twice in the final five weeks, including this week’s trip to Baltimore. The Steelers (minus-8) and Ravens (minus-4) sit atop the division despite a combined point differential of minus-12. The NFC South’s Tampa Bay (minus-22) is the only other division leader on the wrong side of the point differential.

          Vikings thought of the week

          At 4-8, the goal is pretty simple. Have J.J. McCarthy learn and grow on Sundays and not limp and disappear on Mondays.

          ADVERTISEMENT

          NFC North thought of the week

          The Bears (9-3), Packers (8-3-1) and Lions (8-5) make the NFC North one of four divisions that have three teams with records of .500 or better. The Bears are one of five teams leading their division by a game or fewer. And there’s only a half-game separating the NFC top-seeded Bears and the seventh-seeded 49ers (9-4). Should be a fun December for a lot of folks outside the Twin Cities.

          Week 14 picks

          Commanders (+1½) at Vikings: Hold your applause until Monday, which typically is when we find out if any McCarthys were harmed in the playing of said game. Vikings 20-19

          Seahawks (-7) at Falcons: Cheer up, Atlanta. It takes a firing now and then, but everyone eventually claws out from under Kirk’s bloated contract. Seahawks 24-13

          Steelers (+6) at Ravens: Football? Nah. But Rodgers-Thielen will make one heck of a pickleball duo down at the Pittsburgh senior center. Ravens 24-16

          Titans (+4½) at Browns: Over-under on number of times Myles Garrett sacks Cam Ward: However many times Ward doesn’t hand off. Browns 15-6

          Colts (-1½) at Jaguars: Daniel Jones playing on a broken leg while on a one-year contract says only one thing: Fire your agent, Daniel. Jaguars 30-27

          Dolphins (-2½) at Jets: The Jets improve to 2-1 since becoming the last people on earth to realize Justin Fields isn’t an NFL quarterback. Jets 24-23

          Saints (+8½) at Buccaneers: How do the Bucs fix an 0-3 slide against the Pats, Bills and Rams? Play the Cardinals last week, then the Saints and Falcons. Buccaneers 30-14

          Broncos (-7½) at Raiders: To every Raider except Maxx Crosby: On behalf of everyone still alive in a survival pool, thank you for not caring anymore. Broncos 20-9

          Bears (+6½) at Packers: Not-so-fun fact: Caleb Williams and Jordan Love have eight interceptions in 24 games. J.J. McCarthy has 10 in six games. Packers 33-28

          Rams (-8½) at Cardinals: The Cardinals won’t notice in Week 14, but Week 13 proved that even Matthew Stafford ’25 isn’t perfect. Rams 37-20

          Texans (+3½) at Chiefs: Good night, Kansas City. Texans 24-21

          Eagles (-3) at Chargers: Good thing Philly’s defenders have had extra time to heal from that physical and emotional beatdown the Bears laid on them. Eagles 21-17

          Upset special

          Bengals (+5½) at Bills: Dear Justin: Yes, I gave Adam his release to go be with Aaron. But, no, you can’t go play with Ja’Marr and Joe. Love, K.O. Bengals 26-23

          Last week’s pick: Jets (+2½) 20, Falcons 19. Final: Jets 27, Falcons 24. Record: 4-8.

          Season results

          Last week/season straight up: 11-5/109-66.

          Last week/season against the spread: 10-6/78-97.

          Sign up for the free Access Vikings newsletter to get exclusive analysis in your inbox every Friday and complete coverage of every game. Subscribe to the Access Vikings podcast on Spotify, Apple Podcasts and YouTube.

          about the writer

          about the writer

          Mark Craig

          Sports reporter

          Mark Craig has covered the NFL nearly every year since Brett Favre was a rookie back in 1991. A sports writer since 1987, he is covering his 30th NFL season out of 37 years with the Canton (Ohio) Repository (1987-99) and the Star Tribune (1999-present).

          See Moreicon

          More from Vikings

          See More
          card image
          card image