It's been a good week for reader feedback. Here's what some had to say about last week's column on PC disk drives.
Readers Don Kleven of Bloomington and Steve Kurth of King George, Va., said that last week's column about backing up a PC hard drive wasn't as complete as it needed to be.
I was asked whether programs and data could be backed up to an external hard drive, then restored if the PC hard disk failed and had to be replaced. I said no, only data could be backed up and restored to a new PC disk drive; programs had to be reinstalled with a disk or a download.
Casual PC backups do work that way. But Kleven and Kurth noted that an alternative method, using "system image" software, can back up both data and programs, including Windows.
"System image" backups can be made using little-publicized Windows features, such as Windows 7's "Backup and Restore," Windows 8's oddly named "Windows 7 File Recovery" and Windows 8.1's "System Image Backup." The limitation of these programs is that you can't choose specific programs or data to back up and restore; the entire disk is copied and restored.
Some for-pay programs, such as Macrium Reflect ($70) and Acronis True Image ($50), work around that limitation by making a full disk backup the first time, then copying only the files that have changed during subsequent backups.
But "system image" software isn't a good solution for everyone, because many of the programs are difficult to use, Kurth said. "It's easy to make mistakes even if you are knowledgeable."
Kevin Bluml, an Eden Prairie computer consultant, said my advice about testing a potentially failing hard drive should have included a note of caution.