Going old-school: Previews and picks for NFL Week 6 (and a few rants about Week 5)

On the NFL insider Mark Craig takes a spin around the league and finds some players who didn’t learn from past mistakes.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
October 9, 2025 at 6:30PM
Cardinals running back Emari Demercado on Sunday fumbled the ball out of the end zone for a touchback on what appeared to be a touchdown run against the Titans. (Ross D. Franklin/The Associated Press)

Welcome to a weekly look at the NFL’s next round of games. A peek that will be less quarterback-crazy and more about offensive lines, defense, running games, maybe even the occasional punter, and all things that make this the greatest team game ever invented, not the star-driven individualized sport that way too many of us try to make it out to be. An effort will be made to keep the tone somewhere between “Going old-school” and “Get off my lawn!”

Rant of the week

Thanks to the beginning of the end of Jonathan Gannon’s career as an NFL head coach, neither the Cardinals (2-3) nor the Colts (4-1) should have to worry this week about Indianapolis receiver Adonai Mitchell or Arizona running back Emari Demercado letting go of the football before crossing the goal line. One would assume this sudden NFL trend of selfish goal-line gaffes is over after two weeks, but hey, let’s not totally underestimate the next bone-headed modern player who’s more interested in how he looks than doing the job he’s paid to do.

A week after Mitchell’s showboating blunder turned a 75-yard touchdown into a fumble for a touchback in a one-score loss to the Rams, Demercado upped the ante of stupidity by flipping the ball away prematurely on what would have been a 72-yard score and a 28-6 late lead in a game the Cards lost 22-21.

View post on X

The price for that decision was much greater and probably won’t be paid in full until the Cardinals completely distance themselves from Gannon’s viral sideline altercation with Demercado by firing him, probably before Gannon’s third season as head coach is over. The team already fined him $100,000 after he apologized publicly and to Demercado, so good luck regaining control of that roster. And, oh yeah, Gannon has another hole in his sunken ship – he’s become the first coach to lose three straight games on walk-off scores.

Did Gannon go too far by making contact with Demercado’s chest and striking his shoulder pad? Even Mike Ditka himself might say yeah, but let’s tap the brakes a bit. A: You can’t transfer normal human decorum to an NFL game-day sideline, so stop all the “you don’t ever put hands on …” arguments. Even Andy Reid and Travis Kelce have jostled on the sideline. B: Demercado was in pads, and any of us of a certain age who played any level of this game can remember an angry coach slapping a pad or two. C: The mistake was so egregiously selfish and came when every coach in the league was showing clips of Mitchell and telling their players not to be that guy.

Going forward, if you want to look cool, do what the great Earl Campbell used to do after running over an entire defense: hand the ball to the referee after the play is over and the goal line crossed.

Quote of the week

quote

I woke up this morning and didn’t feel great about it, honestly.

Gannon the day after his sideline altercation with Demercado.
It's been an expensive week for Cardinals head coach Jonathan Gannon. (Ross D. Franklin/The Associated Press)

Stat of the week

$49.5 million. That’s the difference per season between what the 49ers are paying starting quarterback Brock Purdy ($53 million) and what they’re paying backup Mac Jones ($3.5 million). Purdy is 1-1 with four touchdowns and four interceptions. Jones is 3-0 with six touchdowns and one interception. Sounds like a great time to give Purdy more time to rest all that ails him.

Game of the week

49ers (4-1) at Buccaneers (4-1). For the first time since 2014, the NFL has no undefeated teams heading into Week 6. The league is also coming off a record-tying six double-digit comeback victories in Week 5 — a feat that’s happened only six times, the last coming in 2013. There are six 4-1 teams, four of which are in the NFC. Two of them meet in Tampa Bay, where the 49ers continue to render anyone else’s injury excuses hollow while the Bucs keep on riding MVP front-runner Baker Mayfield. In last week’s 38-35 win at Seattle, Mayfield went 29 for 33 (87.9%) for 379 yards and two touchdowns to become the first player in NFL history to throw for 375 yards with fewer than five incompletions.

ADVERTISEMENT

How ‘bout a defender for MVP?

Hall of Famers Alan Page (1971) and Lawrence Taylor (1986) are the only defensive players to win league MVP. It’ll never happen again, but an old-school enthusiast who considers Page and not Randy Moss — sorry, SuperFreak — the greatest Viking of all time can dream, eh?

The Jaguars are one of two 4-1 teams in the AFC. The other is Buffalo, captained by reigning league MVP Josh Allen. Jacksonville plays host to Seattle (3-2) having already reached last year’s win total because of a defense that’s snared 14 takeaways, five more than it had all of last season.

Smack dab in the middle of those takeaways is linebacker Devin Lloyd, who has an interception in each of the past four games. His fourth pick was a prime-time doozy. He tricked the one and only Patrick Mahomes into throwing a ball that Lloyd stepped in front of and returned 99 yards for a touchdown – the longest regular-season interception return by a linebacker in league history – in a one-score win over the Chiefs.

View post on X

Lloyd and the Jaguars have a long way to go facing the Seahawks and Rams the next two weeks. But with five total takeaways — the biggest stat besides points — Lloyd is at least in the mix among early MVP candidates.

Did you know?

Believe it or not, the Chiefs (2-3) play host to the Lions (4-1) while having gone 0-3 in one-score games this season. They were 11-0 in one-score games last year and didn’t lose their third game until the Super Bowl. Detroit is 8-2 in its past 10 one-score games, including 1-0 this year.

Vikings wide receiver Jordan Addison celebrates the game-winning TD against the Browns on Sunday after being benched in the first quarter. (Adam Bettcher/The Associated Press)

Vikings thought of the week

Shame on Jordan Addison. And save the “I’ve owned up to my mistake” speeches, and how about you just stop making them? With all Addison has put this team through — forcing it to play three games without him while he was suspended, not to mention having to overpay to bring Adam Thielen home to cover for Addison — Addison has the nerve to miss a walkthrough in London? The reason doesn’t matter. It’s a red flag and reason to fear that more issues lie in wait. Coach Kevin O’Connell had to respond somehow or lose respect, so he benched Addison for a quarter against Cleveland. Addison caught the game-winner at the end, but still, do better off the field for the guy who’s got your back, kid.

NFC North thought of the week

Barring an upset of much bigger proportions than their Week 3 loss to the Browns in Cleveland, the 14½-point favorite Packers, rested from their bye, should raise their record to 3-0 at Lambeau Field with a layup against Cincinnati. That’s good news for coach Matt LaFleur, who won 22 of his first 24 home games from 2019-21 but went 16-10 with three or more home losses each year from 2022-24. The Bengals are 0-2 and have been outscored 76-13 on the road this year.

Buccaneers quarterback Baker Mayfield leads one of the NFL's 4-1 teams, and plays another (the 49ers) on Sunday. (Stephen Brashear/The Associated Press)

Week 6 picks

Eagles (-7½) at Giants: An Eagles team that plays only two good quarters a week won’t need any more than that this week. Eagles, 28-17

Broncos (-7) vs. Jets in London: Whoever said it was better to give than to receive wasn’t talking about the Jets’ turnover differential (8-0). Broncos, 24-16

Cardinals (+6½) at Colts: Just remember, fellas, tossing before crossing turns touchdowns into losses. Colts, 34-24

Rams (-7½) at Ravens: Something about this game made us look up Norm Van Brocklin’s record for passing yards in a game. It’s 554, Matthew Stafford. Rams, 38-20

Patriots (-3½) at Saints: Something about Sunday night’s win over the Bills makes us think Drake Maye’s first game-winning drive won’t be Drake May’s last game-winning drive. Patriots, 23-20

Chargers (-4½) at Dolphins: Jim Harbaugh might not want to ask what’s left of his team, “Who’s got it better than us?” Dolphins, 26-23

Browns (+5½) at Steelers: The Browns move one game closer to Shedeur Sanders becoming the most celebrated fifth-rounder to start at QB for a one-win loser ever. Steelers, 19-10

Cowboys (-3½) at Panthers: Dallas (2-2-1) is one scoring outburst from proving that defense is optional for a winning record through six games. Cowboys, 33-30

Titans (+5½) at Raiders: Something about Geno Smith makes us Google “last Raider to throw nine picks in first five games.” Answer: Josh McCown (2007). Titans, 17-16

49ers (+3) at Buccaneers: Yes, Cleveland, Baker Mayfield is better than Deshaun Watson, Joe Flacco, Dillon Gabriel, Shedeur Sanders and all the other Larrys, Curlys and Moes … Buccaneers, 24-20

Bengals (+14½) at Packers: Unless Myles Garrett was part of the trade, Joe Flacco will not beat the Packers twice in three weeks. Packers, 38-10

Lions (+1½) at Chiefs: Ho-hum. The Lions beat a fifth straight team with a losing record. Easy peasy. Lions, 21-17

Bears (+4½) at Commanders: Say a Hail Mary as you return to D.C., Chicago. Better yet, defend one. Commanders, 19-16

Falcons running back Bijan Robinson plays the Buffalo Bills on Monday night. (Danny Karnik/The Associated Press)

Upset special

Bills (-4½) at Falcons: Bijan Robinson + bye-week rest + homefield advantage on MNF = More national alarm about the breakdowns in Buffalo. Falcons, 30-27

Season results

Last week’s pick: Patriots (plus-8 ½) 34, Bills 28. Final: Patriots 23, Bills 20. Record: 1-3.

Last week/season straight up: 4-9/33-28.

Last week/season against the spread: 5-8/24-37.

about the writer

about the writer

Mark Craig

Sports reporter

Mark Craig has covered the NFL nearly every year since Brett Favre was a rookie back in 1991. A sports writer since 1987, he is covering his 30th NFL season out of 37 years with the Canton (Ohio) Repository (1987-99) and the Star Tribune (1999-present).

See Moreicon

More from Vikings

See More
card image
Elizabeth Flores/The Minnesota Star Tribune

Vikings receiver Justin Jefferson said this season is among the most difficult of his career, but he wouldn’t call it a waste of one of his prime years.

card image
card image