Scoggins: Are the Lynx contenders or pretenders?

After suffering a historic loss Tuesday night, how do the Lynx — the best team in the WNBA this regular season — respond with all the pressure on them?

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
September 25, 2025 at 10:00AM
The Lynx suffered their first loss in team history in which they led by at least 16 points at halftime. Their 20-point blown lead tied for the third-largest in WNBA playoff history. (Jeff Wheeler/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Frustration was evident in their voices, some anger too, but more than anything, the Lynx sounded bewildered by their performance in the second half of Game 2 on Tuesday night.

It’s one thing to lose, but to lose like that? This team?

“Very uncharacteristic,” coach Cheryl Reeve said.

What comes next will reveal a lot about the Lynx.

Playoff wins are gold currency. The Lynx just let one slip out of their hands and roll into a storm drain.

How will they respond?

“Nobody said this stuff was going to be easy,” Reeve said.

The coach who owns a collection of rings knows that rare is the championship that comes easily. Not that her team needed a reminder, but it landed on their doorstep with a thud.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Lynx blew a chance to a take a commanding 2-0 lead in their best-of-five series against Phoenix by unspooling a 20-point lead in a maddening display of turnovers, poor decisions and lack of resolve once the Mercury cranked up their competitive fight.

The Mercury gained new life and confidence — not to mention homecourt advantage — with an 89-83 overtime win. Their 20-point rally tied for the third-largest comeback in WNBA playoff history.

The Lynx suffered their first defeat in franchise history in which they led by at least 16 points at halftime, according to ESPN research. They had been 61-0 in those games.

This wasn’t just any loss. It was historic.

The Lynx were the best team in the WNBA’s regular season by record and just about every important statistical marker. Their dominance and cohesion fostered belief in this season culminating with another championship parade.

They have hit a speed bump.

Championship teams pick themselves up, understand why it happened, learn from it, and push forward.

“It’s a resilient team, a team that responds,” Reeve said after the game. “Obviously, they don’t feel great right now. But they’re problem solvers.”

This one shouldn’t be too complicated to solve.

Start with turnovers. The Lynx opened the door by becoming way too careless with the ball. Yes, the Mercury raised their defensive intensity and pressure, which the Lynx didn’t handle well, but too many turnovers were unforced.

Once the Lynx lost rhythm on offense, it disappeared for the rest of the game.

“I can show you four turnovers right now in a minute-and-a-half that had nothing to do with Phoenix,” Reeve said. “That made us out of sorts.”

The loss of DiJonai Carrington was felt in a major way.

The Lynx got just three points from the bench in Game 2. Carrington, sidelined by a foot injury for the remainder of the playoffs, brought toughness, rebounding, a scoring spark and defensive energy when she stepped on the court. The Lynx must find a solution to her absence.

Reeve noted that Phoenix “ripped the game from us,” and that’s how it looked. The Mercury were down big at halftime and playing their fourth game in seven days but refused to cave to negative circumstances. Their physicality in the second half changed the outcome.

Phoenix coach Nate Tibbetts described it succinctly at the start of his news conference: “Pride and toughness and grit,” he said.

Said Reeve of her team’s response: “We weren’t strong enough. We weren’t tough enough.”

Those are piercing words from a coach, an unmistakable challenge to her locker room. The Lynx played a poor first half in Game 1 and a poor second half in Game 2. Now their playoff path is more difficult headed to Phoenix.

Reeve felt her team “lost our way” in the second half.

The response is what matters now.

The Lynx are a veteran team. A prideful team. And a talented team. Losing in that fashion should inspire a forceful response Friday night.

The Mercury played with a sense of desperation when put into a tough spot. Now it’s the Lynx’s turn to do likewise.

about the writer

about the writer

Chip Scoggins

Columnist

Chip Scoggins is a sports columnist and enterprise writer for the Minnesota Star Tribune. He has worked at the Minnesota Star Tribune since 2000 and previously covered the Vikings, Gophers football, Wild, Wolves and high school sports.

See Moreicon

More from Sports

See More
card image
Jeff McIntosh/The Canadian Press

The Flames scored two goals less than three minutes apart early in the third to take control in the Wild’s first regulation loss in nearly a month.

card image
card image