Michigan man who killed a Duluth woman in front of Duluth bar sentenced to 18 years

Darrius Lamar Plummer, 35, was convicted in May of killing the young mother.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
July 22, 2025 at 10:00PM
The man who stabbed 25-year-old Chantel Raechelle Moose in front of a bar last year was sentenced at the St. Louis County Courthouse after being found guilty in May. (Angelina Katsanis/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

DULUTH – A Michigan man convicted of fatally stabbing a woman in front of a downtown Duluth bar has been sentenced to more than 18 years in prison.

Darrius Lamar Plummer, 35, struck Chantel Raechelle Moose, 25, at bar close on April 12, 2024. She fell to the sidewalk and could not be revived. Plummer was chased, tackled and shot at by two men at the scene before he fled to Detroit, where he was arrested by U.S. Marshals months later.

Plummer, of Canton, Mich., was found guilty by a jury in May and sentenced on Tuesday at the St. Louis County Courthouse, according to a news release.

During the jury trial, Moose was described as well-liked, a mother, a firecracker. She loved music, dancing and art.

“She was like the sparkle in everybody’s eyes,” Moose’s aunt, Tammy DeFoe, said in a video statement after the trial.

Witnesses testified that Plummer said disparaging things about Moose that night at the bar. He stood with his back to the wall, a knife at the ready. She confronted him and he reached over a bouncer’s arm and slashed her near her neck. She didn’t seem to know she had been stabbed, according to witness testimony.

“The last thing Chantel Moose ever did is stand up for herself,” prosecutor Victoria Wanta said at the start of her closing argument.

In the days after her death, a memorial grew on the sidewalk near where she had died.

Several friends and family and at least one child asked Judge Leslie Beiers for leniency in Plummer’s sentence, according to court filings. They said he is kindhearted and that they had never seen him commit violence. He has a 3-year-old daughter and has been a father figure to another young child, according to the letters.

about the writer

about the writer

Christa Lawler

Duluth Reporter

Christa Lawler covers Duluth and surrounding areas for the Star Tribune. Sign up to receive the North Report newsletter at www.startribune.com/northreport.

See Moreicon

More from Duluth

See More
card image
Courtesy: Jeff Rennicke

When the big white bird didn’t head south with its fellow pelicans, the town of Ashland wondered why. Now the bird is getting the help it needed.

card image
card image