Leslie Fhima gets eliminated from ‘Bachelor in Paradise’

A silly error by her love interest, Gary Levingston, set them up for failure.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
August 5, 2025 at 11:57AM
Leslie Fhima and Gary Levingston on "Bachelor in Paradise." (Bahareh Ritter/Disney)

It was an unexpected twist in a two-hour episode where the Minnesota native see-sawed between being at risk and being super safe.

In the first half-hour, Gary Levingston, 66, gave his rose to the Minneapolis fitness trainer even though he gave serious thought to selecting smitten Nancy Hulkower before the ceremony. A third competitor, Natascha Hardee, also had an eye on him.

“I was not expecting to be the hot commodity,” Levingston said.

At that point, Fhima seemed genuinely concerned she may be going home.

“Hopefully, I will get the rose,” she said before she learned she was safe. “Please, please, please.”

Three of the “Golden” daters — Hardee, Hulkower and April Kirkwood — all missed the cut.

With the competition gone, the bond between Fhima and Levingston got stronger.

In one of the two-hour episode’s sweetest scenes, the cameras captured the couple strolling on the beach with Levingston stopping to draw a crude, but cute picture of them in the sand.

“My feelings for him genuinely have surprised me,” Fhima, 66, said.

But Levingston made a major mistake that led to their doom.

After the first ceremony, participants were told they were now competing for a $500,000 prize, taking a page from “Bachelor Pad,” which aired from 2010-2012. Contests would help decide the winner.

In a poker-like game that tested how well each couple knew each other, Levingston and Fhima had a safe spot all wrapped up with a guarantee of finishing in the top three. But Levingston decided to bet all his chips on his guess about Fhima’s thoughts about sex — and lost.

The bad gamble sent them spiraling down to the bottom three and vulnerable for elimination.

“That was by far the dumbest decision in the history of ‘Bachelor in Paradise,’” said competitor Sean McLaughlin.

Their future lay in the hands of the game’s winner, Bailey Taylor Brown, who could decide which of the bottom-three couples would go home.

With tears flowing, Brown told Fhima of her decision.

“I can’t offer you this rose,” she said before giving her a hug.

A Fhima-less “Paradise” continues at 7 p.m. next Monday on ABC.

about the writer

about the writer

Neal Justin

Critic / Reporter

Neal Justin is the pop-culture critic, covering how Minnesotans spend their entertainment time. He also reviews stand-up comedy. Justin previously served as TV and music critic for the paper. He is the co-founder of JCamp, a non-profit program for high-school journalists, and works on many fronts to further diversity in newsrooms.

See Moreicon

More from TV and Media

See More
Kelly Bishop, Lauren Graham, and Alexis Bledel
Robert Voets/Netflix

After years of advice books, children's books and cookbooks inspired by ''Gilmore Girls,'' an upcoming work promises a more personal take on the beloved series. The co-writers are ''Gilmore Girls'' creator Amy Sherman-Palladino and star Lauren Graham.

card image