RandBall: This is the most troubling part of the college transfer portal era

Players getting paid isn’t the problem.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
January 8, 2026 at 5:35PM
Gophers defensive back Koi Perich (3) makes a game-sealing interception while leaping over USC Trojans wide receiver Duce Robinson (2) in 2024. (Alex Kormann/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

College sports have been big business for decades, but the money has only been flowing (legally at least) to players for a handful of years.

It went from a trickle to a heavy stream almost overnight when name, image and likeness (NIL) money overran its original purpose and became paid free agency.

That changed to a fire hose in 2025 with the House settlement stating that schools needed to pay their athletes an additional $20 million-plus per season directly.

Without all that, there’s a good chance Koi Perich would be getting ready for his third season with the Gophers instead of transferring to a national title contender.

But my lament here doesn’t lie so much with Perich. He’s exploiting a system and is about to get paid. And he put in two years with his home-state team, which is two more than his pedigree might have suggested he would.

Like Chip Scoggins wrote about Perich, who reportedly has visits scheduled with College Football Playoff teams Texas Tech and Oregon after entering the portal, this is the business of college football now.

Players getting paid is good for them, even if the system is out of control and everything happened too fast.

ADVERTISEMENT

I can get used to that a lot more easily than the one thing I consider the most troubling part of the portal era. Scoggins summed it up like this:

Imagine if professional athletes were eligible to become free agents after every season. That’s essentially college sports today.

That’s the part of this that isn’t tenable or reasonable, really, for anyone involved. It’s somewhere between devastating and bewildering for fans. It’s crushing for coaches who invest in recruiting and developing players only to have to re-recruit them every year or worse yet lose them when they become stars. In many cases, it creates unhealthy habits and expectations for players, even if the financial gains are undeniable.

If there is going to be unchecked free agency, there also need to be enforceable negotiated long-term contracts for college athletes. There need to be guardrails and expectations instead of a yearly free-for-all.

Otherwise, college sports will continue to operate like a K-shaped economy where the rich get richer and the poor get poorer.

Here are nine more things to know today:

  • The Baltimore Ravens reportedly asked for permission to interview Vikings defensive coordinator Brian Flores for their head coaching vacancy, an unsurprising development that nonetheless is another step toward Flores’ possible departure.
    • The Miami Dolphins on Thursday fired coach Mike McDaniel — who replaced Flores in Miami in 2022. While the Dolphins almost certainly will not do the funniest thing possible and pursue Flores again, Bill Belichick rumors will be fun to watch.
      • Vikings writer Emily Leiker looked at the team’s 2025 rookie class.
        • La Velle E. Neal III was my guest on Thursday’s podcast, which featured a long discussion on the Timberwolves, Gophers men’s basketball and Twins.
          • Our Wolves talk focused on whether their recent surge is real or not. Alan Horton, the team’s excellent radio (and sometimes TV) voice, noted on X that Minnesota is 7-2 in its last nine games against teams with winning records. Five of the Wolves’ next six games, including their next two games against Cleveland, are against teams with winning records.
            • La Velle also wrote about Gophers women’s basketball player Mara Braun.
              • Bobby Nightengale had a great analysis of the Twins’ top 10 prospects and their biggest questions going into next year. We’ll talk more about that on Friday’s podcast.
                • Trae Young getting moved from the Atlanta Hawks to Washington Wizards in what amounts to a salary dump seems about right. He can put up gaudy numbers, but will he help the Wizards win more than 35 games (a bar they haven’t cleared since 2017-18)?
                  • Will the Super Bowl feature a No. 5 seed vs. a No. 6 seed? It’s hard to argue against the logic of Rams vs. Bills.
                    about the writer

                    about the writer

                    Michael Rand

                    Columnist / Reporter

                    Michael Rand is the Minnesota Star Tribune's Digital Sports Senior Writer and host/creator of the Daily Delivery podcast. In 25 years covering Minnesota sports at the Minnesota Star Tribune, he has seen just about everything (except, of course, a Vikings Super Bowl).

                    See Moreicon

                    More from Sports

                    See More
                    card image
                    Lindsey Wasson/The Associated Press

                    The Wild ended their seven-game road trip with a fourth victory that was secured only after they blew a two-goal lead in the third period.

                    card image
                    card image