RandBall: As Twins fade down the stretch, plenty of blame to go around

The seeds for Wednesday’s disappointing loss were planted much earlier. How far back you want to go probably depends on who you want to blame for a sputtering season.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
September 19, 2024 at 4:05PM
Twins starting pitcher Pablo Lopez (49) reacts as he is taken out of Monday's game, a loss that set the stage for another setback Wednesday. (Sue Ogrocki/The Associated Press)

With three outs standing between the skidding Twins and a badly needed win Wednesday, manager Rocco Baldelli looked to his bullpen and called upon Ronny Henriquez.

Henriquez entered the game having achieved pretty good results in 17 previous major league appearances. But his advanced stats showed a pitcher who was perhaps getting by as much on execution as fortune. And more importantly, he had never pitched in a save situation in his MLB career.

It could have worked out, and if it did we would be having a different conversation right now.

But it did not. Henriquez gave up three runs in the bottom of the 10th after the Twins had scored twice in the top half. The 5-4 loss to Cleveland combined with surging Detroit’s win left the Tigers just a half-game back in the wild card race.

The seeds for what happened at the end of the game, though, were planted well before Wednesday. How far back you want to go probably says a lot about who you blame the most for this stretch run collapse — something Minnesota Star Tribune columnist La Velle E. Neal III and I debated on Thursday’s Daily Delivery podcast.

A query posed on Twitter suggests that many Twins fans blame ownership for the Twins’ slump. Those fans might trace the root of Wednesday’s loss, when Henriquez was deemed the best option, to February when Joe Pohlad set the guideposts for team payroll when he said the Twins were not in the market for any big name free agents.

Maybe you want to blame Derek Falvey and Thad Levine? They did nothing at the start of the year to upgrade a rotation that lost Sonny Gray, relying on duct tape and hubris (yes, while constrained by payroll) in hoping that Anthony DeSclafani and/or Chris Paddack would fill the void. Spoiler alert: They did not.

Or let me point you toward the trade deadline in late July. Plenty of functional relief pitchers changed teams. The Twins made a deal for one player: reliever Trevor Richards, who ended up being so bad that they dumped him three weeks later. Surely there were deals available to Falvey that could have given what was then a formidable looking Twins team one or two reliable arms for the stretch run and playoffs.

Perhaps you’d rather dump on manager Rocco Baldelli for decisions like lifting a cruising Bailey Ober after seven innings, one hit, no runs and 83 pitches of a 2-0 game in Kansas City that turned into a 4-2 loss? Not only did the Twins lose that Sept. 7 game, but they ended up needing both Jhoan Duran and Griffin Jax to pitch when one or both of them could have had the night off had Ober gone deeper.

That extra work has piled up as the number of trustworthy relievers has gone down. Jax threw 21 pitches, surrendering the game-losing two-run homer in the process, on Monday. He then had to pitch again Tuesday to close out a win after Duran needed 30 pitches to get four outs. That meant Duran could only go one inning Wednesday and Jax was unavailable. So the 10th went to Henriquez.

Or maybe you are inclined to blame the players? It’s not Baldelli’s fault that Jorge Alcala suddenly couldn’t get anyone out, starting with his blow-up a month ago in Texas that began this massive slide. Twins hitting coach David Popkins, at least to my knowledge, did not tell virtually the entire lineup (led by Royce Lewis) to go into a collective slump that left margins incredibly thin for a fragile pitching staff.

The Twins fans who still have the energy to care are mad, and I don’t blame them. If the Twins continue to falter and miss the postseason after being a virtual lock a month ago — this just two years after they were tied for the AL Central lead in early September only to finish 14 games out by the end — so much of the good will earned last October will be given back.

They have 10 big games and a precious tiebreaker over the Tigers to wrestle back the narrative.

Here are four more things to know today:

  • La Velle and I also talked about the Vikings and NFL rookie quarterbacks.
  • Minnesota United lost 2-1 at home to a strong Cincinnati side, but overall the Loons have started to turn a corner lately.
  • The Packers continue to dabble in the “will Jordan Love play?” game, and it’s pretty annoying.
  • Friday’s podcast will have a strong dose of WNBA coverage, with Kent Youngblood joining me to set up the playoffs for the championship-contending Lynx as well as potential postseason awards that could be coming their way.

about the writer

Michael Rand

Columnist / Reporter

Michael Rand is the Star Tribune's Digital Sports Senior Writer and host/creator of the Daily Delivery podcast. In 25 years covering Minnesota sports at the Star Tribune, he has seen just about everything (except, of course, a Vikings Super Bowl).

See More

More from Sports

card image

After coming back from 18 down in Game 1, the Lynx tried to do something similar in Game 2, but the Liberty persevered with a dozen points in a row at the end.

card image
card image