Tolkkinen: Wakeboat operators need to watch this video

Disturbing footage should prompt owners of these fun but destructive boats to change where they operate.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
July 31, 2025 at 1:21PM
Bethany Anderson, 13, wake boards Friday on Lake Minnetonka in Orono, MN. The Anderson family is among a growing population that participate in the water sport but some home owners on the lake would restrict the use of wake boats that produce the waves for wake boarding.
Bethany Anderson wakeboards on Lake Minnetonka in Orono. Wakesurf boats create fun waves for surfing, but a new University of Minnesota study finds that they can wreak havoc on lake beds. (David Joles/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

It doesn’t take much imagination to realize how fun wakeboats must be.

You bomb along on a sunny day, favorite tunes blasting, friends and family piled in the boat with a pal or a granddaughter surfing your wake, maybe not exactly how it’s done in California, but still amazingly cool for a landlocked state like Minnesota.

Unlike a faster, riskier sport like water skiing, wakesurfing is a relatively gentle lake activity. If you fall, you’re not likely to tear a muscle. You just sink gently into the water.

What is not so easy to imagine is those hidden worlds beneath the wakeboat. After wakeboats pass, the water closes back up, so the revelers have no idea about the destruction they cause below.

Until this week, the rest of us didn’t know, either.

Now we do. The University of Minnesota filmed it and, on Tuesday, released videos that every wakeboat owner, dealer, manufacturer, operator, and lake association should watch. They also released a study that recommends that wakeboats should not go at “semi-displacement mode” (the speed at which they churn the largest wakes) in less than 20 feet of water. That’s the minimum recommended depth. In places where plants grow along the lake bed, they should be 20 feet above the plants.

Researchers filmed lake beds to see what happens when wakeboats pass at depths of 9 feet and 14 feet of water at the speed that creates the most wake.

It’s not pretty.

Things explode.

The sediment at the bottom rocks and flies apart as if struck by a tornado.

Plants rip away from the lake bed.

Water clarity vanishes, replaced by a rocking, drifting cloud of muddy particles that obscure the camera lens. Some of it continues to hang in the water for 15 minutes, until the boat passes over again and stirs it up even more.

icon6:05
University of Minnesota researchers filmed what happens to the lake bed when wakeboats pass overhead. The video was released this week.

You might think, big deal. The sediment subsides eventually. It’ll be fine.

But one of the researchers, Andy Riesgraf of the university’s St. Anthony Falls Laboratory, says that’s not true. Not only does the floating sediment prevent fish from seeing their prey, and prevent sunlight from reaching plants at the bottom, but stirring up the bottom also stirs up a lot of stuff that shouldn’t be stirred up.

“There’s a lot of nutrients in lake bottoms,” Riesgraf said. “You have aquatic vegetation, you have animals dying, and all that sinks to the bottom where it goes through various stages of decomposition.”

Stirring up the lake bed stirs up things like phosphorus that can lead to algae blooms on the lake surface. And that’s bad for everyone, including people who want to wakesurf. It probably also affects mussels and clams and other aquatic life in ways we don’t yet understand.

Don’t you sometimes shake your head at the destruction we unwittingly cause in the name of recreation? Snowmobiles must seem cataclysmic to the mice and voles that live in subnivean zones.

The study also looked at several smaller motorboats, and found that they, too, stirred up sediment. It’s not nearly as much as wakeboats, but it still bothers Jeff Forester. The executive director of Minnesota Lakes and Rivers Advocates uses a 1975 Boston Whaler to cross 11 miles of water to get to his property. It’s not a big boat, but he is newly aware that it can create havoc on the lake bed in shallower water.

“I can cause damage to the lake and drive algae blooms with that boat,” he said. “It gave me pause.”

Wakeboats are already despised in some quarters. Their wakes rock smaller boats, disturb nests and erode nearby shorelines. The same team of researchers who put out this week’s study put out a 2022 report (with the help of crowdfunding) that found that wakeboats cause waves that are significantly bigger and stronger than other recreational boats. In smaller lakes, their activity can affect every other user on the water.

People can be forgiven for not knowing. They’re out on the water, bonding with their families and their friends, having a great time. It’s not readily obvious that what they’re doing is harming the lake bed or leading to algae blooms or eating away at the shoreline.

Now we know.

What do we do next?

What will wakeboat operators do next?

Will they follow the research recommendations that when they are in surf mode, they stay 500 feet away from shoreline and other watercraft and in water that is at least 20 feet deep?

Many lakes don’t meet those specs. Of 1,235 recreational lakes assessed by the Minnesota Department of Natural Resources, only 512 met those criteria, according to figures from the agency. That figure could change depending on lake depths.

That means staying away from shallow, narrow lakes. It means watching the boat’s depth gauges. Some lakes that have lake associations are starting to post maps at boat ramps showing safe wakesurfing areas, which is a great tactic to ensure shared, mutually respectful use of the waters.

Probably many, maybe even most, of them will follow the guidance. Most Minnesotans are good people who want to do the right thing.

The problem is those who think they can do whatever they want because they’re Americans and it’s all about freedom and nobody can tell them what to do.

Let’s hope the latter group doesn’t make regulation necessary.

about the writer

about the writer

Karen Tolkkinen

Columnist

Karen Tolkkinen is a columnist for the Minnesota Star Tribune, focused on the issues and people of greater Minnesota.

See Moreicon

More from Greater Minnesota

See More
card image
Jp Lawrence/The Minnesota Star Tribune

The Minnesota State Patrol said the driver and passenger in one vehicle weren’t wearing seatbelts.

card image