St. Paul man pleads guilty to stealing F. Scott Fitzgerald statue

Investigators arrested Dustan Schmitt days after the 4-foot bronze statue was stolen.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
August 12, 2025 at 5:24PM
Jack Brodt got a closer look at the F. Scott Fitzgerald statue in St. Paul. (Renée Jones Schneider/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

A St. Paul man admitted in court to stealing a bronze F. Scott Fitzgerald statue months after the figure was cut from a building where the late novelist studied.

Dustan Schmitt, 37, pleaded guilty in Ramsey County courts on Friday to the charge of receiving stolen property. Schmitt was arrested days after police reported that the statue was stolen from outside the former St. Paul Academy, where Fitzgerald attended classes. Schmitt initially entered a not guilty plea to the charge in March, but changed his plea for a deal that drops a 2022 case for drug possession and a 2023 case of motor vehicle theft.

Pieces of the F. Scott Fitzgerald statute seized by police after Dustan Charles Schmitt attempted to sell it at Northern Metal Recycling before he was reproted. Schmitt has pleaded guilty. (St. Paul Police Department)

St. Paul police revealed that the statue was stolen on Feb. 11, asking community members to help find the culprit. The statue was commissioned by building owner Ed Conley in 2006. The bronze sculpture depicts Fitzgerald as a teenager, with books in his lap. The piece is valued at around $25,000.

On Feb. 11, a worker from EMR Recycling reported that someone tried to sell them cut pieces of the statue. The worker kept some of those pieces and recorded Schmitt’s name and license plate from a black Jeep.

Investigators closed in on Schmitt and searched his home on the 1100 block of McLean Avenue, finding ID cards and a small green propane tank with a blow torch in his Jeep.

Judge David Brown is scheduled to sentence Schmitt on Oct. 6.

about the writer

about the writer

Kyeland Jackson

General Assignment Reporter

Kyeland Jackson is a general assignment reporter for the Star Tribune.

See Moreicon

More from St. Paul

See More
card image
Leila Navidi/The Minnesota Star Tribune

Jeffrey Lopez-Suazo was one of two men arrested during the raid, which drew hundreds of protesters.

card image
card image