Who should play Prince in new ‘Purple Rain’ musical? We dream about 8 choices.

Our critics dissect the pros and cons, from Bruno Mars to Timothée Chalamet to Janelle Monae.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
August 9, 2025 at 7:44PM
Prince performs in his debut movie "Purple Rain," the 1984 rock opera about a young man's search for artistic accomplishment and love.
Prince performs as the Kid in his 1984 debut movie "Purple Rain," which is being adapted into a stage musical. (The Associated Press)

We soon expect to hear who will play the Kid, the lead role in the stage adaptation of Prince’s movie “Purple Rain” that will premiere in October in Minneapolis before heading to Broadway.

The casting team has two major considerations when it comes to a headliner: pick someone who is already a star or go with an unknown who has the chops. Both have benefits and risks.

A celebrity would bring a following but that fan base may disappear when that star exits the show. And could the producers afford to pay a princely sum for a big name?

An unknown lets the focus be on the music and the show, which is probably a more sustainable model in the long run. Think “Hamilton,” and “MJ,” the Michael Jackson musical.

To be clear: No one can play Prince. No one should even try. He was the complete rock star, multitalented in so many ways. The actor will be playing the Kid, the character portrayed by the Purple One.

The upcoming musical is using the story of “Purple Rain” to inspire the production, not try to recreate it onstage.

So we decided to play casting directors and fantasize which celebs could play the lead role in the “Purple Rain” musical.

Bruno Mars has the Uptown Funk to bring to the role. (Kai Z Feng/Atlantic Records)

Bruno Mars

Rohan Preston: He’s got that falsetto, dance moves and star power, not to mention the swagger. That suggests that Mr. Silk Sonic can subsume his own Uptown Funk enough to become the Kid.

Jon Bream: Although he can sing, dance and play multiple instruments, he can’t do all of them as well as Prince. Plus, he’ll turn 40 in October. Sorry, too old to play the Kid.

FILE - Lenny Kravitz appears during a portrait session in New York on May 20, 2004. In a new memoir, "Let Love Rule," Kravitz explores his childhood and ends with him on the verge of stardom and deeply in love with actress Lisa Bonet. (AP Photo/Jim Cooper, File)
Lenny Kravitz's age and hair would not let love rule in "Purple Rain." (Jim Cooper/The Associated Press)

Lenny Kravitz

RP: True, Lenny’s got that Prince-ly mystery, that charisma and natural cool. He’s talented as heck and can get into the high registers. I just worry about him doing the splits. And if does the splits, would he be able to get up after?

JB: With his New York bravado, he has often come across as a Prince wannabe. So would this be on the nose? He’s the right size and certainly has the vocal and guitar expertise. Can he dance like the Kid? Will he cut off his dreadlocks? Although Kravitz looks ageless, he is 61. Fuhgeddaboudit.

Cynthia Erivo arrives at the Oscars on Sunday, Feb. 9, 2020, at the Dolby Theatre in Los Angeles.
Not only does Cynthia Erivo have deep talents but she has extra time and your kiss. (Richard Shotwell/Invision/The Associated Press)

Cynthia Erivo

RP: She was not even in the conversation until she showed up at Coachella Valley Music and Arts Festival to do “Purple Rain” with music director Gustavo Dudamel and the Los Angeles Philharmonic. So, she’s got the vocal range, the versatility and perhaps the best theatrical chops of anybody. Why not?

JB: She’s a multi-hyphenate who can do it all: convincingly become a character, sing with extraordinary passion and dance with flair and abandon. But can she play guitar? Not with those fingernails.

Timothee Chalamet did his homework to portray Bob Dylan but could he become a quick study to play Minnesota's other music icon? (Gregorio Borgia/The Associated Press)

Timothée Chalamet

JB: Don’t laugh. He pulled off Bob Dylan in “A Complete Unknown” last year and brought thousands of young people to the movie theaters. He was light on his feet in 2023’s “Wonka.” So if he could learn to sing and play guitar like Dylan, could he learn to … never mind.

RP: You’re onto something, though. Prince contained multitudes, right? And he adopted the fused symbol for male and female. Besides, the appeal to a new generation is a consideration. Hmmm.

We might be fallin' for Alicia Keys as the Kid if her stage name were Alicia Guitar. (Jerry Holt/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Alicia Keys

RP: We shouldn’t sleep on Ms. Keys. She has the sensibilities, the instrument talent (even though she rocks out on piano instead of guitar) and the squealy mix of innocence and power that Prince epitomized. Besides, we already know that she would slay “How Come U Don’t Call Me Anymore.”

JB: She definitely has the Prince connection. Remember she inducted him into the Rock & Roll Hall of Fame? She knows that no one can play Prince. Nonetheless, Keys brings theatrical and musical prowess. She has Tonys and Grammys to prove it. I guess if she’s stationed behind a piano she won’t have to dance much. But would that be a Purple state of mind?

Fans would cry for the Weeknd if His Royal Darkness played Prince. (Richard Shotwell/The Associated Press)

The Weeknd

JB: He’s dark and mysterious, befitting the Kid. He can sing, with a masterful falsetto, just like the Kid. But can Abel Tesfaye truly act beyond playing the kind of creepy character that is the Weeknd in videos and films? We’ve never seen him dance. Thanks for auditioning. Next.

RP: I suppose he could play Prince in his nameless, brooding Slave era but that’s in the future for this story. Prince has some downhome qualities that don’t seem innate to the Weeknd, who comes off as a little stiff and not as connected to his soul.

Austin Butler won a Golden Globe Awards for portraying the King. Could he renounce the crown to play Prince? (Chris Pizzello/The Associated Press)

Austin Butler

JB: He credibly transformed himself into the King for “Elvis” in 2022. Can he relinquish the crown to play Prince? Oops, I mean the Kid. Butler has the acting chops. Elvis moves are not Princely moves. And does Butler have the vocal range? This might be too big of a stretch.

RP: He’s pretty, yes, and he’s a little tall. You would have to scale everything up to play the short king.

FILE - In this Aug. 12, 2013 file photo, American R&B and soul musician, composer and record producer, Janelle Monae poses for a portrait at Dream Downtown, in New York. The Grammy-nominated singer released her full-length sophomore album, “The Electric Lady,” on Tuesday, Sept. 10, 2013. It features collaborations with Prince, Erykah Badu, Miguel, Esperanza Spalding and Solange. (Photo by Victoria Will/Invision/AP, File) ORG XMIT: MIN2013091808522241
Janelle Monae manifests the proper prowess and regalness to portray her pal. (Victoria Will/Invision/The Associated Press)

Janelle Monáe

JB: She can act, she can dance, she can sing, spectacularly all. I don’t care if we don’t know about her guitar prowess. She has the size, the look, the moves, the dramatic skills and the “It” factor to be the Kid. And a bonus: She and Prince were pals and collaborators. She is my choice.

RP: Ooh, she’s got the look. I remember being spellbound by her performance at the Varsity in Minneapolis back in 2010. Prince was in the audience for that “Tightrope” show. She would be electric as the Kid.

about the writers

about the writers

Jon Bream

Critic / Reporter

Jon Bream has been a music critic at the Star Tribune since 1975, making him the longest tenured pop critic at a U.S. daily newspaper. He has attended more than 8,000 concerts and written four books (on Prince, Led Zeppelin, Neil Diamond and Bob Dylan). Thus far, he has ignored readers’ suggestions that he take a music-appreciation class.

See Moreicon

Rohan Preston

Critic / Reporter

Rohan Preston covers theater for the Minnesota Star Tribune.

See Moreicon

More from Stage & Arts

See More
card image
Raging Art On at Gamut