NFL Week 3 preview and picks: What has gotten into kickers?

The Minnesota Star Tribune’s NFL insider Mark Craig can’t believe what’s happening with kickers, needs fans to quit crying over injuries and regrets last week’s Lions pick.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
September 18, 2025 at 6:29PM
Brandon Aubrey is so good that the Cowboys essentially took a knee so he could kick a 64-yarder against the Giants on Sunday. (Matt Patterson/The Associated Press)

Welcome to a weekly look at the NFL’s next round of games. This will be less quarterback-crazy and more about offensive lines, defense, running games, maybe even the occasional punter, for gosh sakes, and all things that make this the greatest team game ever invented, not the star-driven individualized sport that way too many of us try to make it out to be. An effort will be made to keep the tone somewhere between “Old-School” and “Get off my lawn!“

Week 3 rant

Yeah, yeah, kickers are players, too. But they’ve become too good for the good of the game. Shrink the goal posts! A year after kickers made a record 195 field goals from 50-plus — topping the records of 158 and 154 the previous two years — they’re 31 of 37 (83.8%) from 50-plus this year. Hall of Fame kicker Jan Stenerud played 263 games. He made 17 of 64 (26.6%) from 50-plus with a long of 55. The Cowboys’ Brandon Aubrey has played 36 games. He’s 27 for 30 (90%) from 50-plus and is so automatic even from 60-plus (his range Sunday was set in pregame warmups at 71) the Cowboys essentially took a knee so he could kick a 64-yarder to send last week’s game against the Giants into overtime. And no one batted an eye or broke a sweat.

Quit griping about injuries

Dear Vikings Nation: You are not unique. Injuries are everywhere! As long as the NFL refuses to practice hard or play anybody in the preseason, players are going to suffer more injuries when their bubble wrap comes off and they’re asked to go from soft to 60 for three hours a week. Each division has a 2-0 team. Four 2-0 teams — Arizona, Indianapolis, Cincinnati and San Francisco — didn’t make the playoffs last year. The Bengals and 49ers both lost star quarterbacks and won with backups. The 49ers are being decimated throughout their entire depth chart, but this week they play one of two games featuring two undefeated teams. Mac Jones, who posted a 113.1 passer rating against the Saints, starts in place of Brock Purdy again as the 49ers host the Cardinals in an NFC West matchup.

Stats are for losers

Cleveland hosts the 2-0 Packers with a defense that’s ranked No. 1 in yards allowed (191.5) by 37½ yards over No. 2 Atlanta. The Browns held the Bengals to 141 yards and the Ravens to 242 yards. And … they’re 0-2 with the sixth-worst scoring defense (29.0). The Packers have the sixth-best scoring offense (27.0).

Stat of the week

14. The league-leading number of pressures for reigning NFL sack king Trey Hendrickson, whose Bengals visit a Vikings team that has allowed the league’s third-worst pressure percentage (29.6).

Quote of the week

quote

I trust this group.

Chiefs coach Andy Reid, who’s 0-2 for the first time since 2014.

Reid isn’t ready to concede the end of the Patrick Mahomes-era dynasty. Kansas City plays Sunday night at the 0-2 Giants, who got 450 yards and one bone-headed, game-killing interception in last week’s overtime loss to the Cowboys.

Dunce of the week

Kaleb Johnson, Steelers running back/now-former kick returner. Johnson, a third-round pick, did the rest of the league’s return men a favor by reminding them the hard way that kickoffs are once again live balls in the end zone. In a 31-17 home loss to Seattle, Johnson forgot that pretty important detail by not retrieving a kickoff that bounced over his head. Seattle recovered in the end zone for a touchdown. Pittsburgh gave up 30 points twice last year. They head to New England having given up 30 points twice in two games this year.

Did you know?

In spite of coach Shane Steichen’s horrendous game management at the end of the Broncos game, the Colts are 2-0 for the first time since 2009. With Daniel freaking Jones at quarterback, Indy heads to 0-2 Tennessee as the first team in the Super Bowl era not to punt in its first two games.

ADVERTISEMENT
Vikings tight end Josh Oliver signed a big contract extension this offseason, but hasn't been used much in the first two games. (Carlos Gonzalez/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Vikings thought of the week

If you’re paying Josh Oliver, shouldn’t you play Josh Oliver? The Vikings’ pass protection has been atrocious. The left tackle situation is a disaster. The Vikings are paying Josh Oliver $8 million a year. They call him the best blocking tight end in football. And … they played him 19 snaps (25.7%) in the Falcons debacle and only 41 snaps (40%) through two weeks. Hmmm.

NFC North thought of the week

Upset Special?! Boy, did I underestimate Detroit’s desire to show the world that former offensive coordinator and now Bears head coach Ben Johnson isn’t the only reason Detroit has had the league’s best offense since 2022. Johnson’s Lions scored 52 points twice last year. And that’s what this year’s Detroit team laid on Johnson. Next up: A trip to Baltimore on Monday night to face an uncharacteristic Ravens team that’s giving up a league-worst 40 points a game.

Game of the week

Rams (2-0) at Eagles (2-0). Philly took down the Chiefs in the Super Bowl rematch thanks to No. 1 Swiftie Travis Kelce’s drop-turned-back-breaking-pick. Now, it’s time to face the NFC’s sleeper team in a rematch of last year’s divisional playoff game that was a one-score game (28-22) despite Saquon Barkley’s 205 yards rushing. Philadelphia is going for its third 3-0 start in five years under coach Nick Sirianni.

The Vikings' Myles Price returns a kick Sunday against the Falcons. (Carlos Gonzalez/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Question for Vikings KR Myles Price

Before Kaleb Johnson’s blunder in Pittsburgh, did you know that kickoffs are once again live balls in the end zone under the new rules?

“Yeah, I knew. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Man, my heart goes out to Kaleb. I would hate for that to happen to me. I’m undrafted. That’s a lose-your-job type of moment for me. [Special teams coordinator Matt Daniels] every week shows us clips of guys forgetting a rule or making some kind of mistake. I was in the room with him [Tuesday], and Kaleb Johnson was the first clip he showed me.”

Week 3 picks

Dolphins (+11½) at Bills: Most Valuable Player (Josh Allen) faces Least Likely Coach to Survive ‘25 (Mike McDaniel). Bills 34, Dolphins 20

Bengals (+3) at Vikings: Let the inevitable QB controversy begin! Vikings 19, Bengals 13

Jets (+6½) at Buccaneers: So much for the Jets’ Week 1 moral victory. They still stink. Buccaneers 31, Jets 17

Colts (-4½) at Titans: Daniel Jones looks like this year’s Sam Darnold. (Ever think that would have been considered a compliment?) Colts 24, Titans 17

Raiders (+3) at Commanders: Week 2 Geno Smith looked nothing like Week 1 Geno Smith. Commanders 19, Raiders 14

Falcons (-5½) at Panthers: J.J. McCarthy has confirmed that the Falcons have indeed finally found a pass rush. Falcons 23, Panthers 19

Texans (+2½) at Jaguars: Sorry, Vikings fans, but you only get to play the AFC South every four years. Jaguars 21, Texans 16

Packers (-7½) at Browns: Sorry, Vikings fans, but you must play the Packers twice this year. Packers 26, Browns 12

Steelers (-1½) at Patriots: The Steelers’ defense is so bad, even the Vikings’ offense is licking its chops to get to Ireland for Week 4! Patriots 34, Steelers 26

Broncos (+2½) at Chargers: Chargers reach 3-0 for the first time since 2022 with Jim Harbaugh proving likeability not required to win coach of the year. Chargers 24, Broncos 21

Saints (+7½) at Seahawks: Careful, Spencer Rattler. Don’t play so well that the Saints can’t replace you. Seahawks 31, Saints 21

Cardinals (+2½) at 49ers: Proof that this is a team game, Kyler Murray is 2-0. 49ers 28, Cardinals 25

Chiefs (-5½) at Giants: More proof that this is a team game, Patrick Mahomes is 0-2. Chiefs 34, Giants 28

Cowboys (+1½) at Bears: Brandon Aubrey stays home and still kicks the game-winning field goal from his home in Dallas. Cowboys 23, Bears 20

Lions (+5½) at Ravens: Yes, Detroit, I am still doubting you. Just not as badly as picking the Bears (d’oh!) last week. Ravens 31, Lions 24

Rams quarterback Matthew Stafford threw for 298 yards and two TDs against the Titans on Sunday. (Jeff Haynes/The Associated Press)

Upset of the week

Rams (+3½) at Eagles: Let the Old Man Stafford 4 MVP campaign begin! Rams 24, Eagles 23

Season record

Last week’s upset special: Bears 21, Lions 17. Final: Lions 52, Bears 21. Record: 0-1.

Last week straight up: 10-6.

Last week against the spread: 6-10.

Sign up for the free Access Vikings newsletter to get exclusive analysis in your inbox every Friday. Subscribe to the podcast on Spotify, Apple Podcasts and YouTube.

about the writer

about the writer

Mark Craig

Sports reporter

Mark Craig has covered the NFL nearly every year since Brett Favre was a rookie back in 1991. A sports writer since 1987, he is covering his 30th NFL season out of 37 years with the Canton (Ohio) Repository (1987-99) and the Star Tribune (1999-present).

See Moreicon

More from Vikings

See More
card image
Elizabeth Flores/The Minnesota Star Tribune

Vikings receiver Justin Jefferson said this season is among the most difficult of his career, but he wouldn’t call it a waste of one of his prime years.

card image
card image