RandBall: J.J. McCarthy’s authentic state is the hour between dog and wolf

The young Vikings quarterback is only 22 when he steps onto the field.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
November 6, 2025 at 6:33PM
J.J. McCarthy, somewhere between a dog and a wolf. (Star Tribune, AP photos)

(NOTE: Would you like to be alerted when I post new content? Sign up here to get one — and only one, I promise — email delivered to your inbox.)

There exists a fantastic phrase that, when translated from French, thankfully does not lose its oomph: “The hour between dog and wolf.”

We can parse it three ways, or at least we could until recently.

Literally, it is meant to describe twilight — the time when day melts into night, but it is not fully either of the two.

Figuratively, you could interpret it to mean an uncertain time when there exist multiple possibilities or versions of what be illuminated or hidden in shadows.

And in a popular book from 2013 borrowing the phrase for its title, author John Coates describes “what happens to your body when you engage in risk-taking.” Coates, a physiologist and former Wall Street trader, shows that risk can transform someone into a different person.

Now, though, we have a fourth application of the hour between dog and wolf, which I talked about on Thursday’s Daily Delivery podcast.

It is J.J. McCarthy, or sometimes “Nine” as he said Wednesday in describing how a “switch gets flipped” on gamedays that allows him to channel his intensity and turn a normal smile into a piercing, focused glare.

ADVERTISEMENT

“I kind of like feeding that wolf,” McCarthy said, noting that he was known for having a smiley face on his hand during a very successful college career at Michigan. “There is a lot of power that comes from that built-up anger that you can transmute into your performance.”

McCarthy is not dog or wolf; his authentic state is both, and it is remarkable that he is able to both use it and articulate it at such a young age.

His on-field play is very remindful of what a 22-year-old should be doing. His performance is uneven, imperfect, breathtaking in one moment and cringeworthy the next.

There is nothing about his personality that suggests he is 22. Sometimes he sounds like he’s 15 and sometimes he sounds like he’s 100.

It feels too cheap to label his personality an “intangible” quality, but there is something to be said for how he has won at every level of football and how he seems to save his best moments for the ones that matter most.

In that time, in that space, he is operating in the hour between dog and wolf. His authenticity reminds me of Anthony Edwards, even if the expression of it is different, and McCarthy is fortunate to have a head coach who understands him beyond Xs and Os.

“The guys look at him, and they see J.J. McCarthy being himself. That’s all I’ve ever thought quarterbacks in the league need to do. Much like a head coach, you have to be authentically yourself every single day,” Kevin O’Connell said Wednesday. “He’s absolutely that. That’s what allows him to be ready for the moments in games where he’s answered the bell twice now in two divisional road games.”

Here are nine more things to know today:

  • Not to extend the metaphor, but the Wolves played like dogs in the second half of Wednesday night’s 137-114 trouncing at the hands of the New York Knicks. Where is the defense?
    • The only good news: Edwards returned from a hamstring injury that ended up only costing him four missed games.
      • Also on Thursday’s show, La Velle E. Neal III joined me for an extended conversation about the Twins and new manager Derek Shelton. His most recent column is full of good information and hits on some of the things we talked about.
        • ESPN ranked the top 50 MLB free agents. Will the Twins be in the mix with any of them?
          • I hate that I missed the anniversary Wednesday, but it was Nov. 5, 1989, when Jerry Burns went off on his epic, profanity-laced rant.
            • The Vikings will have their hands full Sunday with a desperate Baltimore Ravens team that is returning to health. Baltimore is a 4½-point favorite even though the game is at U.S. Bank Stadium.
              • Having Andrew Van Ginkel will be a good start. The Vikings are 3-0 in games he has played this year and 1-4 without him.
                • The Gophers have had a good football recruiting week, and it continued Wednesday.
                  • Friday’s podcast will feature ex-NBA player Randy Livingston. He will discuss his former gambling addiction and relate it to current scandals.
                    about the writer

                    about the writer

                    Michael Rand

                    Columnist / Reporter

                    Michael Rand is the Minnesota Star Tribune's Digital Sports Senior Writer and host/creator of the Daily Delivery podcast. In 25 years covering Minnesota sports at the Minnesota Star Tribune, he has seen just about everything (except, of course, a Vikings Super Bowl).

                    See Moreicon

                    More from Sports

                    See More
                    card image
                    Jerry Holt/The Minnesota Star Tribune

                    The former New York star shot 7-for-9 in the fourth quarter and finished with 25 points against his old team.

                    card image
                    card image