Souhan: Max Brosmer is not the Vikings’ backup QB of the future

The Vikings beat the Lions with little help from Brosmer, who isn’t the answer behind J.J. McCarthy, no matter how much you like the former Gopher’s feel-good story.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
December 26, 2025 at 3:45AM
Vikings quarterback Max Brosmer (12) is sacked by Lions star Aidan Hutchinson (97) in the first quarter at U.S. Bank Stadium on Thursday, Dec. 25. Brosmer was sacked seven times in the game and needed a fourth-quarter completion produce net positive passing yards on the day. (Elizabeth Flores/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Before you fall for an endearing storyline, ask yourself whether it makes sense.

Ask yourself, for instance, whether a quarterback who had played one year at a major college football program and went undrafted should really be expected to thrive as an NFL rookie.

Ask yourself whether a player performing well in the disorganized practices known as preseason games is a reason for optimism, and whether your familiarity with someone’s name because they played college ball down the street is a valid way of evaluating a prospect.

Then ask yourself the question of the moment: When was the last time you saw a quarterback performance as sickly as the one produced by your favorite backup quarterback, Max Brosmer, against Detroit?

That the Vikings won 23-10 on Christmas Day at U.S. Bank Stadium is a testament to their defense and the collapse of the so-recently-formidable Lions.

Against a poor defense and playing at home, Brosmer completed nine of 16 passes for 51 yards. He was sacked seven times for 48 yards. Only a diving catch by Justin Jefferson in the fourth quarter kept the Vikings from being the second team since 2006 to win a game with negative cumulative passing yards.

Two years ago, Brosmer was playing for New Hampshire against schools like Stonehill, which sounds like a winery with a desk and a whiteboard.

Last year, Brosmer played pretty well for the Gophers.

ADVERTISEMENT

This year?

Ski-U-Meh.

At least recent developments have made the immediate future of the Vikings quarterback room clear.

J.J. McCarthy is the franchise quarterback until he proves he doesn’t deserve that title.

Brosmer belongs on the practice squad, at best.

Carson Wentz didn’t do enough to earn the backup job.

So the Vikings should be in the market for just the right kind of backup — one who is affordable and capable, and dedicated to being a good mentor for McCarthy.

I don’t know who that will be, but the Vikings have to do better next year at choosing a backup quarterback than they did this year.

To recap:

They traded for Sam Howell, then realized that he was a hot mess and traded him away.

They signed Wentz in late August because he was unemployed and available.

They resorted to Brosmer, who made two starts this season, and looked abysmal in both, throwing four interceptions in a shutout loss at Seattle and looking overwhelmed again against the Lions.

The chances of Brosmer becoming a successful NFL rookie quarterback were that of a snowball in Jacksonville.

In recent NFL history, there have been two quarterbacks who have gone undrafted and become stars: Kurt Warner and Tony Romo.

Warner got to hone his skills in the Arena League, and then he didn’t start until his second season in the NFL. Romo didn’t start an NFL game until his third season.

Brosmer might never be ready to play well in the NFL. He had no chance of doing so this year.

This isn’t even a criticism of Brosmer, one of tens of thousands of quarterback prospects who aren’t good enough to play in the NFL.

This is a criticism of the Vikings for failing to find a better alternative …

And the unserious analysis of his chances that led to unrealistic expectations …

And the homerism that led Minnesotans to think that Brosmer had a chance to immediately play better than quarterbacks with more talent and experience.

With a fourth consecutive victory, the Vikings are 8-8.

That means if they had managed the position of backup quarterback better, they might have been in position to make the playoffs.

After the game, Vikings coach Kevin O’Connell was diplomatic, saying that this wasn’t an offensive performance he would “put on my shelf,” while praising Brosmer for avoiding turnovers.

Brosmer smiled and said: “Lots of learning, man. NFL football is hard.”

The Vikings went 5-4 when McCarthy started this year, and 3-4 when he didn’t.

A better backup quarterback might have gotten the Vikings to 10 wins and a playoff berth.

Enabling two nice local stories — Wentz’s return and Brosmer’s promise — might have destroyed the Vikings’ chances.

about the writer

about the writer

Jim Souhan

Columnist

Jim Souhan is a sports columnist for the Minnesota Star Tribune. He has worked at the paper since 1990, previously covering the Twins and Vikings.

See Moreicon

More from Vikings

See More
card image
Anthony Souffle/The Minnesota Star Tribune

Jones has handled 44 touches within a five-day span against the Lions and Giants despite a growing list of injuries.

card image
card image