Neal: It’s official … Twins will be sellers

The news of Chris Paddack being traded to the Detroit Tigers indicates Twins President Derek Falvey has finally picked a side ahead of the MLB trade deadline.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
July 29, 2025 at 1:12PM
When the Twins traded a starting pitcher, Chris Paddack, they sent a message about their plans near the trade deadline. (Mark J. Terrill/The Associated Press)

Twins President Derek Falvey is a loquacious yet tight-lipped executive. He’s savvy at providing content without revealing his plans.

That’s fine. In this case, it’s better to focus on his actions and not his words.

On Sunday, Falvey was noncommittal about his approach to the trade deadline. On Monday, Falvey acted. And now Chris Paddack and Randy Dobnak are members of the Detroit Tigers.

With one move, the white flag is hoisted, and taps are playing as the Twins’ wild-card hopes are nearly dashed. It signaled what this week will look like — one during which pending free agents will be moved while waiting to see if someone will overpay for the Twins’ most coveted, under-control players.

The year began with a lingering bad taste of a 2024 season during which the Twins crumbled down the stretch. Their efforts went into getting off to a fast start in 2025, which didn’t happen. The 13-game winning streak in May was a tease. There have been more injuries, blended with maddening lack of production from core players. Losing had-to-have-it series against Miami, Colorado and Washington this month sealed their fate.

More moves are expected this week, as there should be. Trading a starting pitcher amid the current state of the rotation — with Pablo López and Bailey Ober injured and manager Rocco Baldelli resorting to bullpen games — tells it all.

Paddack, a capable back-end rotation arm, was hit with the news while he drove to the ballpark before the series opener against Boston. He later made phone calls to make sure his new team was on board with him going through with his scheduled bullpen session Monday, which he received clearance to do.

Afterward, he met with reporters while DaShawn Keirsey and Zebby Matthews looked on. Once that was completed, Harrison Bader came over to hug him, and Brooks Lee wanted to meet him for dinner next week when the Twins visit the Tigers — where Paddack might face his suddenly former team.

ADVERTISEMENT

How many times will this scene be repeated this week?

“We haven’t even gotten to Thursday yet,” Baldelli said, “and you know, we’ve had to already call Chris in and let him know [he’s been traded]. So again, it is emotional. It’s not like a very normal day.”

Baldelli now will be tasked even more to keep a clubhouse focused as trade talks leak into the media this week. I believe the scene involving Paddack will be repeated a few more times before Thursday’s deadline.

One thing Falvey has made clear is that he abhors straddling at the deadline. And this is a great time to see what’s available and move on from guys who likely won’t be back next year anyway. Teams, regardless of market size, get out of salary commitments if they aren’t in contention.

The Twins likely weren’t bringing back Paddack. And the fact that they were able to include Dobnak, who is making $3 million in the final guaranteed year of his contract, means the Twins will save about $3.5 million in salary. Since Detroit is taking on salary — especially in agreeing to take on Dobnak’s — that affects the return.

So welcome 19-year old switch-hitting catcher Enrique Jimenez, who is in rookie ball. He’s years away from the majors, if he reaches the majors.

Let’s look at the rest of the free agents-to-be in Twinstripes, and how appealing they are to teams.

  1. Willi Castro: I noticed his belt has WC 50 on it. His initials also stand for “World Champion,” and Castro seems destined to land on a contender down the stretch. The 2024 All-Star is speedy, switch-hits and has played everywhere except first base and catcher. His 110 OPS+ is above average. I’m surprised the Yankees dealt for Ahmed Rosario instead of Castro, but they have coveted Rosario for years. Castro has achieved much here and has earned a move up the standings.
    1. Danny Coulombe: Coulombe has a 2.40 ERA since the start of 2020 but an excellent 1.16 ERA through 31 innings this season. There’s always a need for lefthanded relief. This would leave Kody Funderburk as the main lefty, but this is where the Twins are. Besides, if this sets up a late-season debut of Connor Prielipp — he’s starting at Class AA Wichita but could thrive as a reliever — I’m all for it.
      1. Harrison Bader: Bader’s 2.4 WAR is third best on the team. He will steal a few bases, provide some pop and play Gold Glove-worthy defense. A good fourth outfielder or platoon piece. Teams are always looking for those.

        Ty France hasn’t hit like a first baseman and therefore has no value. Christian Vázquez has even less. I don’t expect them to be moved.

        Castro, Coulombe and Bader form the group of pending free agents Falvey has a good chance of trading this week. The three players still under control for two years — Joe Ryan, Griffin Jax and Jhoan Duran — would land better players. The Phillies have had four scouts on Jax and Duran over the last month, including their top assistant. If I had to pick one, I would deal Jax and keep the younger Duran.

        Ryan? I would have to be overwhelmed to move him. He should be part of the future, and should be signed to a long-term contract. The Twins could always move him during the offseason if the sides can’t settle on a number.

        Monday was St. Paul Saints Day at Target Field. The Twins should have waited a week to hold the event. Because there will be more Saints players here to replace the players Falvey should deal this week.

        about the writer

        about the writer

        La Velle E. Neal III

        Columnist

        La Velle E. Neal III is a sports columnist for the Minnesota Star Tribune who previously covered the Twins for more than 20 years.

        See Moreicon

        More from Twins

        See More
        card image
        Mike Janes

        Winokur, a 6-foot-6 shortstop and center fielder, hit .226 with 17 homers, 68 RBI and 26 stolen bases in high Class A this year.

        card image
        card image