Souhan: Sho-Time indeed. Shohei Ohtani’s performance was distinctively incredible.

In an era of specialization, hitting three homers and pitching six scoreless innings in a playoff game boggles the mind.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
October 20, 2025 at 9:00PM
The 31-year-old Shohei Ohtani has already won three MVP awards during his major league career, which started in 2018. (Ashley Landis/The Associated Press)

Before Shohei Ohtani, baseball history offered one example of a premier slugger who was also a premier pitcher and excelled at both disciplines in the postseason.

His name was Babe Ruth.

Ruth, though, never hit a home run in a postseason game in which he pitched.

The Babe was the most transformational player in baseball history. He took a game that revolved around bunting and slapping singles and imbued it with the majesty of power.

Ruth was a standout pitcher for the Boston Red Sox and the most dominant slugger in baseball history for the New York Yankees.

Ruth, though, never did what Ohtani did in the National League Championship Series and never had to compete against players of color or deal with a succession of hard-throwing relievers.

In Game 4 of the NLCS on Friday night, Ohtani pitched six scoreless innings, struck out 10, hit three home runs and drew a walk. Ohtani came as close as anyone ever has to producing the ideal baseball performance.

He became the 12th player to hit three home runs in a postseason game. Ruth, who did it twice, is the only player to do so more than once.

ADVERTISEMENT
View post on X

Ohtani’s achievement is so remarkable that it’s difficult to find apt comparisons.

Imagine Patrick Mahomes throwing three touchdown passes and also intercepting three passes. That could never happen.

Imagine a goalie, in the Stanley Cup playoffs, earning a shutout — and scoring three goals. That could never happen.

Ruth is the one player in baseball history who conceivably could have matched Ohtani’s Game 4 performance, but he never did.

This year, in the NFL, Jacksonville rookie Travis Hunter has played on offense and defense. And in doing so, he has realized how difficult it is to be a competent player on both sides of the ball in one game. On Sunday, the Jaguars used him mainly on offense.

The only modern athlete who could be cited as being as spectacularly versatile as Ohtani is Bo Jackson, an all-star performer in baseball and football. But even Jackson didn’t try to pitch.

The one sport in which athletes can display Ohtani-like versatility and dominance is basketball. But basketball is engineered so the best athletes can take the most shots, grab the most rebounds, block the most shots and compile the most assists.

In baseball, you can’t run a play for your best player. Ohtani had to face a championship-caliber lineup and had to hit the pitches available to him in his at-bats.

A pitcher is the most important player on a baseball diamond. Ohtani allowed the fewest possible runs while pitching.

The home run is the ultimate offensive achievement in baseball. Ohtani hit home runs in each of his official at-bats.

Dodgers two-way star Shohei Ohtani reacts after one of his three home runs during Game 4 of the NLCS on Friday night in Los Angeles. (Ashley Landis/The Associated Press)

Sports fandom tends to overreact to this kind of greatness. Those who gush are accused of being prisoners of the moment.

Lock me up. I can’t imagine a more difficult or distinctive feat than Ohtani’s.

If a baseball player had done something similar between 1920 and 1980, before football became the United States’ dominant sport, there would have been many books written about him, as well as epic poems.

Instead, Ohtani made history on a Friday night of a packed sports weekend in a game that doesn’t even try to compete with the NFL anymore. Which is a shame.

Given the global nature of modern baseball and the uniqueness of his feat, Ohtani, who is Japanese, should be considered the world’s premier athlete.

Shohei Ohtani pitched six scoreless innings Friday night as the Dodgers beat the Brewers 5-1 to sweep the NLCS. He struck out 10 and gave up just two hits. (Ashley Landis/The Associated Press)

Because baseball has become a regional sport in America, and because Ohtani uses an interpreter to conduct interviews with English-speaking journalists, he isn’t as central to American sporting culture as he should be.

Maybe he shouldn’t do as many national commercials as Peyton Manning, but he should be more in demand than Cooper and Arch.

For those who still care about baseball, and there are many millions of us, there is a consolation to watching Ohtani’s feat be treated like just another football highlight. We get to watch him in the World Series, pitching, hitting and perhaps again combining both in a way that’s never been done before.

about the writer

about the writer

Jim Souhan

Columnist

Jim Souhan is a sports columnist for the Minnesota Star Tribune. He has worked at the paper since 1990, previously covering the Twins and Vikings.

See Moreicon

More from Sports

See More
Concordia-St. Paul volleyball coach Brady Starkey.
The Minnesota Star Tribune

The Golden Bears, who are vying for a record 10th national championship, will take on Gannon on Thursday at the Sanford Pentagon in Sioux Falls, S.D.

card image
card image