Advertisement

Deficit isn't a bureaucrats' scheme

September 16, 2010 at 2:04PM

Republican gubernatorial candidate Tom Emmer has taken to referring to state government's projected $5.8 billion 2012-13 deficit as "what government wants to spend." It's a line he used repeatedly in Wednesday night's BringMeTheNews debate. He's conjuring the image of self-serving bureaucrats dreaming up numbers to reflect gluttonous appetites for taxpayer dollars. He then adds that the projected deficit does not reflect the will of the people.

On the contrary: those numbers spring directly from the will of the people, as expressed the way it always is in a representative democracy -- through the decisions of duly elected representatives.

The spending forecasts made by officials at Minnesota Management and Budget are grounded in decisions made by the Legislature through the past half-century. Those decisions illustrate lawmakers' wise preference for distributing government services equitably around the state -- rather than, say, on the basis of who voted for whom in the last election. Thus, school funding is based on the number of students a district serves. Health care for the poor flows to those below a certain income threshhold, and with certain independently assessed medical needs, regardless of who or where they are. Aid to cities and counties is similarly formula-driven.

The deficit projection flows directly from those formulas. For example, school spending is forecast to increase nearly $1 billion from 2010-11 to 2012-13 because K-12 enrollment is expected to grow by more than 10,000 students.

When Emmer talks about spending less on those sorts of programs, he is evidently calling for changes in those formulas -- though he has yet to own up to what those changes might be. That's a crucial piece of information for voters as they assess Emmer's proposal for a "no new taxes" solution to the state's budget problem. He's not just proposing to disappoint a few greedy bureaucrats. He's talking about spending reductions that will affect nearly every Minnesotan.

Advertisement
about the writer

about the writer

Lori Sturdevant

Columnist

Lori Sturdevant is a retired Star Tribune editorial writer and columnist. She was a journalist at the Star Tribune for 43 years and an Editorial Board member for 26 years. She is also the author or editor of 13 books about notable Minnesotans. 

See Moreicon
Advertisement
Advertisement

To leave a comment, .

Advertisement