Brooklyn Park Police Department clears officers who responded to Hortman slaying

One of the officers exchanged gunfire with the suspect. An internal investigation found they followed policy and training.

The Minnesota Star Tribune
November 5, 2025 at 2:38AM
At least 100 law enforcement officers, including local police, sheriffs and the FBI, gather less than a mile from the home of Rep. Melissa Hortman in Brooklyn Park on June 14. (Alex Kormann/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

An internal investigation has cleared two Brooklyn Park police officers who waited more than an hour before entering the home of a Minnesota politician who’d been gunned down inside — a delay that raised questions over law enforcement response to the brutal slaying.

The preliminary review, which is common after incidents involving use of deadly force, found officers Zachary Baumtrog, who “discharged his duty handgun,” and Jay Bloyer followed policy after arriving at DFL Rep. Melissa Hortman’s home early in the morning of June 14, according to a news release.

However, the Brooklyn Park Police Department is still requesting a broader third-party review of the response and communications surrounding the incident, said department Inspector Matt Rabe.

Baumtrog and Bloyer “proactively conducted a check” at the Hortman residence around 3:30 a.m. June 14, after responding to the shooting at the Champlin home of DFL state Sen. John Hoffman, according to police.

The officers attempted to rescue Mark Hortman, who was bleeding in the doorway, according to the review conducted by the Brooklyn Park Police Department. According to the review, released Tuesday, neither officer “was aware of any other victims in the home at the time.”

“The department’s preliminary review determined that Officer Baumtrog’s use of deadly force, along with the actions of both officers, were consistent with Brooklyn Park Police Department policy and training,” the review concluded.

According to initial reports, the officers witnessed the suspect shoot Mark Hortman and enter the house.

“You had the officers shooting at the suspect, the suspect shoots Mark right in the entryway, he goes in the house and he starts shooting in the house,“ Brooklyn Park Police Chief Mark Bruley said in June. ”It’s really, really chaotic. As they called ‘shots fired,’ lots and lots of resources came. They converged on the house."

After the firefight, officers didn’t go inside the house until 4:38 a.m., according to timestamps on bodycam footage. They waited for a drone to be deployed to see if Boelter was inside and if Melissa Hortman was still alive.

Bruley has said his officers believed they shot the suspect and that he was “holed up” in the basement.

The man charged with killing the Hortmans is Vance Boelter, a 57-year-old who state and federal criminal charging documents say disguised himself as a police officer and went on a shooting spree of DFL lawmakers whose names he carried on a list. Around 2 a.m., before going to the Hortmans’, Boelter reportedly traveled to Hoffmans’ home and shot the senator and his wife, Yvette, multiple times, leaving the couple badly injured, charges say.

The assassination of the Hortmans shocked the nation, drawing condemnations of heightened political violence across the ideological spectrum. It also brought criticisms over spotty police communication among multiple agencies, and the officers’ hourlong wait before entering the Hortman home.

It’s unclear who will conduct the third-party investigation. Legislative Auditor Judy Randall told the Minnesota Star Tribune earlier this year that her office has received requests to do so.

Jeff Day and Ryan Faircloth of the Minnesota Star Tribune contributed to this story.

about the writer

about the writer

Andy Mannix

Investigations

Andy Mannix is an investigative reporter for the Minnesota Star Tribune.

See Moreicon

More from Twin Cities Suburbs

See More
card image
Anthony Soufflé/The Minnesota Star Tribune

A Minnesota Star Tribune analysis of test scores shows which of the state’s public schools have exceeded expectations.

card image
card image