To say exchange-traded funds are enjoying a moment right now is an understatement — they are the darlings of the investing world. In the first two months of 2018, new funds launched at a pace faster than one per day. And a recent survey conducted by BlackRock found that 62 percent of investors planned to buy an ETF in the next 12 months.
Despite their popularity — or perhaps because of it — ETFs have attracted detractors. These assets, which track an index of securities much like a mutual fund and trade like stocks, are by no means new: The first ETF debuted in the U.S. 25 years ago. But there is still skepticism about how safe they are, especially when the market crashes. (It has been a while since this happened, but here is what you need to know about a stock market crash.)
The idea that ETFs will be riskier during a sell-off is typically bandied about by mutual fund managers, who pick individual stocks, a task at odds with the passive nature of ETFs. Suffice it to say, some ETF detractors may have a personal incentive to steer investors away from these assets.
Still, the notion that your ETF holdings may be riskier than you realize is worth exploring, not least because this idea surfaces in the financial media regularly. Here is a look at the two main arguments — and what you need to know about ETF risks in general.
1. ETFs are 'untested.' The argument: The ETF market of today hasn't experienced a market crash and could be vulnerable in the next one.
The reality: While the growth in ETF assets has coincided with the current bull-market cycle, there have been opportunities for ETFs to be tested even if the market hasn't succumbed to a prolonged sell-off.
Most notable were a couple of "flash crashes" — one in May 2010, the other in August 2015 — when the market fell sharply and quickly and ETF prices weren't trading in lockstep with their underlying assets, as they are supposed to do.
Since the 2015 flash crash, however, the industry has made a lot of changes — including shoring up trading technology and changing some rules and regulations — to prevent this from happening again, said Martin Small, managing director and head of BlackRock's U.S. iShares, the largest ETF provider. Proof that those changes have worked came in February when the S&P 500 fell 4.1 percent and 3.8 percent on two separate days.