Xcel nuclear plant down again

The Monticello facility was shut down for the second time in two years after a breaker failure.

September 15, 2008 at 8:46PM

Xcel's nuclear generating plant in Monticello automatically shut down late Thursday night, the second unplanned shutdown in two years.

A breaker failure at a substation prompted the shutdown and the plant switched to off-site power sources, Xcel officials announced early Friday morning.

Plant personnel worked Friday to fix the equipment and said they expect to restart the plant "in the near future." There were no injuries. No radiation was released. Officials emphasized there was no threat to the public.

In January 2007, the Monticello plant closed for a week after a 35,000-pound control box broke loose from its support beams and fell onto a large pipe carrying radioactive steam. The pipe did not rupture or leak.

In August, Xcel shut down one of its two Prairie Island reactors because of elevated hydrazine levels found in the turbine building. Levels of the anti-corrosive, ammonia-like chemical stayed elevated for about six hours before being corrected. The plant was back to full power the next day.

The problems at both nuclear plants concerned some Minnesota environmentalists and Indian tribes who worry about plant safety and excessive radioactive waste storage.

Concern has heightened since Xcel applied to extend operating licenses for both of its Minnesota-based nuclear plants.

In February, Xcel asked the Minnesota Public Utilities Commission (PUC) to approve a $135 million expansion in Monticello that would add 70 megawatts to the plant's current 600-megawatt capacity. The plant generates about 10 percent of Xcel's power. Last year, Xcel received a license from the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC) to extend operations until 2030.

In April, Xcel Energy asked the NRC to extend its operating license on two Prairie Island reactors by 20 years. The current 40-year operating licenses are set to expire in 2013 and 2014.

Xcel's extension requests are among many pouring into the NRC as more states look to nuclear power as a carbon-free solution to rising energy demand and global warming fears. The NRC received 13 applications for 19 new reactors this year. In 2007, there were only five applications.

Chuck Laszewski, spokesman for the Minnesota Center for Environmental Advocacy, said environmental groups are split on nuclear plants, with some advocating for the non-carbon-emitting plants while others oppose them, citing the need for nuclear waste storage, the lack of a permanent waste depository and potential safety problems surrounding aging plants.

The Center for Environmental Advocacy unsuccessfully opposed Xcel's request to increase nuclear waste storage at the Monticello nuclear plant nearly two years ago.

The Prairie Island Indian Community has voiced similar concerns about safety and Xcel's large waste storage plans near Red Wing.

Tribal Council President Ron Johnson said the plant is too old and that after 40 years, certain equipment may not adequately handle upgrades and expansions. The tribe, which learned about the Monticello shutdown Friday afternoon, will testify at next month's hearing before the Public Utilities Commission, Johnson said.

Dee DePass • 612-673-7725

about the writer

about the writer

Dee DePass

Reporter

Dee DePass is an award-winning business reporter covering Minnesota small businesses for the Minnesota Star Tribune. She previously covered commercial real estate, manufacturing, the economy, workplace issues and banking.

See Moreicon