A single misheard word, man for eye. The words don't even sound alike. But with that simple misperception, one person's values and core beliefs had been fundamentally misapprehended.
How often do similar misunderstandings occur every day? How often do we send an e-mail or text whose tone is misperceived, and the recipient never asks for clarification?
And what about my values? If the woman had been light-skinned, would I have said, "I saw a white woman with a black eye, and I wondered if she was safe?" Am I guilty of subconscious profiling?
Our deepest assumptions are subtly revealed. Consider the title of Gay Talese's book, "Thy Neighbor's Wife." Change the gender to "Thy Neighbor's Husband" and you realize that our society's tendency is to think of maleness as the norm and femaleness as the exception, as Casey Miller and Kate Swift point out in "The Handbook of Nonsexist Writing."
Even having this conversation is risky. It's safer to hide behind a veneer of politeness and politically correct statements, as illustrated so revealingly in the Guthrie Theater's production of "Clybourne Park."
When I saw the woman at the Y, I asked myself, how often do people get black eyes from accidents? When my wife sees a doctor or nurse, she's routinely asked if she feels safe at home, but it wasn't my place to say something to a stranger.