When Brian Dozier watches highlights of Shohei Ohtani, the Angels rookie who pitched six solid innings last Sunday to beat the Athletics, then homered as Los Angeles' DH on Tuesday, Wednesday and Friday, he is reminded of … Drew Butera?
Wait, better let him tell it.
"Remember when Drew Butera came in to pitch in Milwaukee?" Dozier said of a 2012 blowout loss to the Brewers in which the then-Twins' backup catcher, now with the Royals, took the mound for the ninth inning to preserve the bullpen. "He has a cannon, and he was sitting at like 92 [miles per hour] with ease. Easy cheese, and he could hit 94, 95. There are guys out there who could play both ways if given the chance."
It's debatable whether there are many players who could deliver star-level performances in both disciplines like the Angels believe Ohtani will; Butera, after all, is a career backup, not an All-Star. But the notion of a true two-way player was a common topic in the Twins clubhouse last week, and Ohtani's challenge clearly intrigues his peers around the game. "I can imagine it," Twins slugger Logan Morrison said, "because I've wanted to do it."
There are instances of players who have given up one side to try the other; new Hall of Famer Trevor Hoffman, for instance, was an overwhelmed middle infielder for the first two years of his pro career before turning himself into one of the greatest closers in history, and former Cardinal Rick Ankiel enjoyed a seven-year career as an outfielder after his promising pitching career was derailed by control problems.
Dozier drew a walk against his former Twins teammate, outfielder-turned-pitcher Jordan Schafer, during a spring training game against St. Louis in February, and the Twins considered using the overall No. 1 pick last June on Brendan McKay, a Louisville star now both pitching and playing first base in the Rays system.
Two-way players are obviously rare, and there's a reason.
"We're talking about some of the best athletes in the world. You can't tell me there aren't guys who could do it. There are guys in this clubhouse who probably could," Dozier said. "But 162 games is so strenuous, there's so much wear and tear on your mind and body, that adding to [your workload] is going to take a toll on your game. And there's too much at stake for that."