Second-guessing after two blowout playoff losses tends to be low-hanging fruit and ultimately an exercise in futility. When you get outscored 18-6, as the Twins did Friday and Saturday combined against the Yankees, would a handful of borderline decisions really have affected the outcome?
Maybe not. But …
These three decisions by the Twins and manager Rocco Baldelli were fair to wonder about before they had negative consequences. So these aren't outcome-based questions even if the outcomes were poor.
1. Starting Luis Arraez on Friday over Jonathan Schoop at second base. Arraez was a big reason the Twins surged to the AL Central title. But the lefthanded Arraez was also coming off an ankle sprain. Defense hasn't been his strong suit this season to begin with.
If ever there was a time to play the righthanded and more sure-handed (and strong-armed) Schoop, it was against lefty James Paxton in Game 1. Arraez missed a short popup at the start of New York's three-run third. His double-play relay throw was low later in the inning (though the error was charged to C.J. Cron). Schoop probably makes both plays look easy. The Yankees scored three runs, turning a 2-0 Twins lead into a 3-2 deficit in an eventual 10-4 game.
2. The bullpen use Friday was questionable. Zack Littell has been good this year, but he might not be my first choice in the fifth inning right after tying the score 3-3. His two batters (walk and hit by pitch) both scored after Tyler Duffey was pressed into relief.
It was still just 5-4 in the sixth, but the next two relievers were Cody Stashak and Kyle Gibson — who honestly might have been the last two guys to make the 12-man playoff pitching staff. I get not wanting to burn all your top relievers while trailing, especially with another game looming Saturday, but if you really believe in your offense shouldn't you give the team the best chance to rally? Stashak and Gibson gave up five runs combined. Game over.
3. Duffey was the first call out of the pen in the third inning Saturday — even after throwing 25 high-pressure pitches Friday — when the Twins had several very well-rested options. He came into a 1-0 game, bases loaded, nobody out. Six runs later, the Yankees had blown the game open.