Stratasys sued after earnings disappointment

Law­suit alleges the company in­flat­ed earn­ings fore­casts.

February 7, 2015 at 3:11AM
(Evan Ramstad/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Days af­ter investors pum­meled Stratasys Ltd. for post­ing sur­pris­ing­ly dis­mal earn­ings re­sults, the 3-D print­ing firm wel­comed a slight re­prieve in its stock de­cline. How­ever, the down­ward slide start­ed a­gain Fri­day as the first of sev­er­al threat­ened law­suits was filed.

The law firm Rob­bins, Gel­ler Rudman & Dowd sued Stratasys, al­leg­ing it vio­lat­ed Security and Exchange rules by in­flat­ing earn­ings fore­casts for 2014. Oth­er firms launched in­ves­ti­gat­ions this week, seek­ing plain­tiffs who also might be in­ter­est­ed in su­ing Stratasys.

The brou­ha­ha start­ed Tues­day when Stratasys sur­prised investors with news that it would take a $100 mil­lion charge for the fourth quar­ter and suf­fer a loss for the en­tire fis­cal 2014 year. Of­fi­cials said they now ex­pect to lose $116 mil­lion to $129 mil­lion, or $2.32 to $2.58 a share.

The Eden Prairie man­u­fac­tur­er took the good­will im­pair­ment charge re­lated to its MakerBot con­sum­er print­er busi­ness. Stratasys bought MakerBot in 2013 for $400 mil­lion. The charge may ex­ceed MakerBot's es­ti­mat­ed annu­al rev­e­nue.

Four Wall Street ana­lysts this week down­grad­ed Stratasys' stock from buy to hold. As of Fri­day, only Ga­bel­li & Co. bucked the trend, up­grad­ing its rat­ing to "buy."

The stock im­plod­ed Tues­day, drop­ping from $80.06 to $51.75, be­fore clos­ing at $57.36. That's a level not seen since 2012. The stock re­cov­ered early Fri­day to $63, but then fell a­gain af­ter the law­suit was filed. It closed Fri­day at $61.37 a share.

Stratasys of­fi­cials could not be reached for com­ment on the lat­est de­vel­op­ments.

How­ever, in a state­ment re­leased earli­er this week, Stratasys found­er and Chairman Scott Crump, de­fied the hoop­la. "Our growth in fis­cal 2014 was im­pres­sive, we ex­peri­enced es­ti­mat­ed rev­e­nue growth of 54 percent com­pared to fis­cal 2013, in­clud­ing or­gan­ic rev­e­nue growth of 31 percent."

"Stratasys' pros­pects for 2015 and be­yond are strong," he said. "We con­tin­ue to see ad­di­tive manu­fac­tur­ing be­ing used to trans­form manu­fac­tur­ing pro­cess­es across a wide range of sec­tors, aug­ment­ing our lead­ing po­si­tion in prototyping ap­pli­ca­tions. We are also ex­cit­ed about our op­por­tu­ni­ty to build upon MakerBot's lead­ing po­si­tion in desk­top 3-D print­ing."

Stratasys has been a fast-grow­ing com­pany and a long time Wall Street favorite giv­en its booming tech­nol­o­gy, which uses com­puters, CADD soft­ware and melt­ed plas­tic to in­ex­pen­sive­ly man­u­fac­ture three-di­men­sion­al parts and pro­ducts.

Stratasys makes com­mer­cial and con­sum­er 3-D print­ers and sep­a­rate­ly manu­fac­tures pro­ducts for cus­tom­ers on a con­tract ba­sis. Cus­tom­ers in­clude General Motors Co., Ford Motor Co., and Delta Air Lines.

Stratasys has dual head­quar­ters in Re­ho­vot, Is­ra­el, and in Eden Prairie.

Dee DePass • 612-673-7725

about the writer

about the writer

Dee DePass

Reporter

Dee DePass is an award-winning business reporter covering Minnesota small businesses for the Minnesota Star Tribune. She previously covered commercial real estate, manufacturing, the economy, workplace issues and banking.

See Moreicon

More from Business

See More
card image
card image