State legislator out of touch with Catholic values

February 14, 2012 at 1:16PM
U.S. Army Spc. Derek Griffard from Santa Maria, Calif., holds a rosary from his first communion, which he carries as a good-luck charm in Mosul, northwest of Baghdad, Iraq on Thursday, March 27, 2008. "When your life is at risk, you just try to hold on to anything that you think will help keep you going and get you home safe to see your family," said Griffard.
U.S. Army Spc. Derek Griffard from Santa Maria, Calif., holds a rosary from his first communion, which he carries as a good-luck charm in Mosul, northwest of Baghdad, Iraq on Thursday, March 27, 2008. "When your life is at risk, you just try to hold on to anything that you think will help keep you going and get you home safe to see your family," said Griffard. (Elliott Polk (Clickability Client Services) — Associated Press/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Counterpoint

I am not sure exactly what it is that state Rep. John Lesch, DFL-St. Paul, was arguing for in his meandering commentary ("The bishops: One-way on a two-way street," Feb. 10).

But it is hard to interpret it as anything other than an attempt to delegitimize as both legally suspect and out-of-step with American values the Catholic Church's rights to speak in the public square and serve the public without unreasonable governmental interference.

Lesch's remarks may delight the acolytes of Planned Parenthood, but they could have negative consequences, particularly for those who are cared for by nonprofits such as the Catholic Church.

Lesch is a lawyer, so he should know better that all nonprofit, tax-exempt organizations -- religious and secular, and not just the ones who agree with him -- are free to advocate (within broad limits) for what they believe is good legislation, without sacrificing their IRS status.

The separation of church and state does not mean that the public and those in power are insulated from having to listen to and consider the perspectives of people of faith.

Let's put aside the smokescreen that the speech of religious actors is somehow an illegitimate or unwarranted "intrusion" into politics.

JASON ADKINS

The writer is executive director of the Minnesota Catholic Conference.

about the writer

about the writer

More from Commentaries

See More
card image
Richard Tsong-Taatarii/The Minnesota Star Tribune

Calls for de-escalation and toning down the rhetoric in recent days is exactly what was needed, even if it might have felt like capitulation.

card image

Opinion | What happens after our shock fades?

card image