It's not too late for the principal who said "no" to sashes at South St. Paul Secondary school's commencement to change his mind ("Graduation sashes are flash point at school," front page, April 23). The comment that "every policy or procedure we roll out can be in place for the next 100 years. … I want to make sure it's right" is absolutely wrong. Words on paper can change with the will of the people in the room to recognize a better idea. I will be an advocate for public schools until my dying breath, voting "yes" for anything that gives kids what they need to hit full potential and walk that stage with pride. Schools are a public institution; professional educators don't need three months to think about a proposal for an event that will happen next month. Let the kids come back with a plan for a one-year experiment designed to be respectful of the majesty of the moment. Work with them to design sashes that make everyone recognize how successfully the district has served every one on their path to that stage. With one change of heart — the principal's — students could spend their last days of school creating a visual spectacle worthy of news coverage that promotes positive public school success and affirms how the school supports individual achievement in life beyond academics. That kind of flexibility and respect for diversity will ensure the future of public schools for 100 more years.
Wendy Wustenberg, Farmington
• • •
I'm offended by this multiethnic/multicultural group of South St. Paul Secondary seniors who want to wear "identity adornments" to their graduation ceremony, some of them in particular wanting to wear sashes that display flags of their "nations of origin."
Such a display of dual loyalty and, in my opinion, un-Americanism should be considered an insult to those who, like me, see America as a land of opportunity, not a land of intolerance and injustice. The very fact we accept tens of millions of recent immigrants, both legal and illegal, living here speaks for itself.
School graduation ceremonies are supposed to be about celebrating academic achievement, not pushing political agendas represented by raised black fists and rainbow flags. Most schools, I'm sure, wouldn't tolerate MAGA hats instead of traditional mortarboards, and almost certainly wouldn't tolerate sashes that say "Trump 2020" on them, either.
I am fully aware of the 1969 Supreme Court case (Tinker vs. Des Moines) that upheld the free speech rights of students. Nevertheless, the South St. Paul school board should reject these students' demand.
And if the students dare to show up wearing their sashes anyway, let them be escorted from the ceremony and have their diplomas mailed instead.
Mark Overholser, South St. Paul
HEALTH CARE
Fox News probably knew what it was doing with Sanders town hall
Since Fox News promotes what is good for American corporations, I am not surprised that outfit put cameras on a Bernie Sanders town-hall meeting in a studio packed with a live audience. Unlike David Feinwachs, who expressed his amazement in an April 24 commentary that the Fox News audience showed enthusiasm over "Medicare for All," I am not amazed. Rather, I suspect that Fox News was simply preparing the way for the sharpest health insurers to keep peddling Medicare Advantage policies to Americans. Currently, Medicare pays only 80% of the costs of its insureds. The insureds need to pay, on their own, the remaining 20% of their health care costs. Many of those insureds see the need to purchase Medicare Advantage or Medicare Supplemental policies to cover that 20%. And they will buy those policies from private health insurance corporations … definitely a conservative scenario.
Diane J. Peterson, White Bear Lake
BREXIT
Actually, with democracy in action, a close vote with many sitting it out
An April 24 letter regarding Brexit ("Editorial Board is perilously close to thumbing its nose at democracy") contained a significant misstatement. It said that 52% of the British population voted to leave, but that percentage actually applies to the number of votes cast, not the total population. In fact, about 17.5 million people voted to leave, 16.2 million voted to remain, and 12.9 million didn't vote. Hardly overwhelming.