Rand: Wins for U, Vikings still leave fans unhappy — but they shouldn't be

December 30, 2015 at 1:44AM
Minnesota head coach Tracy Claeys is doused with a sports drink after winning the Quick Lane Bowl NCAA college football game against Central Michigan, Monday, Dec. 28, 2015, in Detroit. Minnesota won the game 21-14. (AP Photo/Carlos Osorio)
Several happy Gophers doused head coach Tracy Claeys with a sports drink after winning the Quick Lane Bowl. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

We're in that strange space between Christmas and New Year's, and those who didn't get outside on Sunday probably haven't seen the sun in a good two weeks.

Maybe you're tired, bored, stressed or just a little crankier than usual. So perhaps the local reaction to a couple of recent football victories shouldn't be all that surprising.

Still, there's this: anyone who ventured into the Startribune.com comments sections (note: do this at your own peril) to see what fans had to say about the Gophers' win over Central Michigan in Monday's Quick Lane Bowl, and to a lesser extent some reactions to Minnesota's win over the Giants on Sunday, found that some people can't be pleased no matter what happens.

The Gophers' Quick Lane Bowl appearance Monday wasn't literally a no-win proposition, but it sure felt that way. If Minnesota would have lost to Central Michigan, putting an unflattering bow on a 5-8 season, the naysayers would have pounced on the opportunity to declare the loss was one more bit of proof that the Gophers will never be good.

But that didn't happen. Minnesota won 21-14 in a balanced game. That didn't dampen the spirits of those who wanted to discredit the program, though.

The talking points: The Gophers almost lost to a bad team; they still finished with a losing record; they didn't even deserve to be in the bowl game in the first place.

Even some of the compliments were laced with sarcasm. A sample of the Bronx cheers: "YAY!!!! Almost a .500 season!!!!"

Perhaps it's a good time to remember this, on the heels of both the Quick Lane Bowl and the Vikings' victory over the Giants: a win is a win. You can only play who is on your schedule. If your starting point is to discredit what transpires, win or lose, based on the quality of opponent, meaning of the game or both, then what's the point of even caring or watching?

ADVERTISEMENT

Certainly the Gophers recognize Monday's victory for what it was: a nice way to end a disappointing season, a victory that broke a seven-game bowl losing streak, and a victory that — despite what some might think — in every way possible was better than the alternatives of either not playing or playing and losing.

Same goes for the Vikings, who took advantage of a disinterested Giants team and cruised to a playoff berth Sunday. Beating a bad team is sure better than losing to a bad team.

It is possible to maintain that perspective and relish a victory, even if it appears some fans just want to be unhappy no matter what.

Michael Rand

about the writer

about the writer

More from Sports

See More
card image
Jeff Wheeler/The Minnesota Star Tribune

Talbot Ward and Wyatt Wolfe gave the Ponies their first championship in the event.

card image