Opinion | An open letter to the Annunciation School families and community from a former Minneapolitan

It hurts when it happens here — because “here” is so much a part of us, wherever we are.

September 26, 2025 at 8:59PM
Community members gathered at Lynnhurst Park in Minneapolis for a candlelight vigil Aug. 27: The loss, writes Dick Schwartz, remains vivid even to people "from the outside." (Jeff Wheeler/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Opinion editor’s note: Strib Voices publishes a mix of guest commentaries online and in print each day. To contribute, click here.

•••

My wife and I recently moved from southwest Minneapolis to Chicago. From afar, it’s been hard to watch what’s happened at Annunciation School because Minneapolis still feels like home and probably always will. We feel like we should be there, sharing the grief, anger and even numbness with you, our friends, neighbors and community.

Over the past weeks, I’ve been scanning published photos and footage on CNN, the New York Times, the Minnesota Star Tribune and other local, national and worldwide news sources. What I see are ordinary neighborhood folks like you and me.

At first, it was the all-too-familiar, desperate, deflated expressions on your faces, the ones we’re all familiar with, the ones that speak volumes in one sentence:

“How could this have happened here?”

I know your neighborhood well. “Here” is an easy bike ride from the Fulton neighborhood, where my wife and I lived, to Annunciation School and your idyllic Windom neighborhood. I know that neighborhood well. So do folks where I now make my home and those living in greater Minnesota. That’s because chances are good they’re living in one just like it. Their version of “here.”

“Here” is leafy Pearl Park, where my own kids played soccer and tennis with a thousand other kids when they were young.

“Here” is near their favorite second home, the local throwback Dairy Queen.

“Here” is the corner coffee shop across the street from Annunciation School, where retirees and parents toting strollers meet each morning.

“Here” is the nursing home down the block. I know that Annunciation kids visit with and perform for its residents, especially at Christmastime.

“Here” is the welcoming public library almost kitty-corner from Annunciation; next to it flows Minnehaha Creek. In summertime, the creek lazily floats kids in inner tubes all the way to Minnehaha Falls Park.

“Here” is in the late afternoon, when you’re sitting at a study table next to one of the bay windows that face Annunciation, and you’ll witness its students, kindergartners through eighth-graders, wearing their once morning-tidy but now unkempt school uniforms. They’re riding bikes, skateboarding or walking in twos, threes, fours and fives, some of the older ones with tiny brothers and sisters in tow. The little ones’ backpacks look heavier than the bodies schlepping them.

“Here” is where many of the Annunciation kids stop at the local library to chill, gain a second wind before going to a playground, a practice, their Boy or Girl Scout meetings or home. Just ordinary kids like you’d see anywhere doing ordinary kid stuff.

“Here,” only a few blocks east of Annunciation, stands the highly regarded, old but stately Washburn High School. This past August, Washburn celebrated its hundredth anniversary and storied history. Next to it is a junior high, recently renamed “Justice Page Community Middle School” honoring Alan Page, retired Minnesota Supreme Court judge (and, of course, Minnesota Vikings Hall of Fame defensive end).

“Here” is where folks would love to live, believe me.

And, now, “here” are all of you wonderful folks, committed to doing all you can to ease the pain still in so many hearts and minds.

From what we’ve seen in the reportage, the Annunciation family feels heartfelt gratitude for that, of course. But one member of the family has said even that at nighttime and alone, it’s still especially hard. Her greatest fear is that it wouldn’t be long before people “from the outside” would put this tragedy in the back pages of their minds.

“It’ll be just another shooting that happened,” she said.

Not so fast. Recently, here in Chicago, I was at a local dog park, engaged in one of those friendly but banal dog-park conversations we dog owners have about our pets — except, when we’re very lucky, talk deepens to more personal life stories and the state of the world, the kind we want to share but most of the time don’t, won’t, sometimes even can’t.

At the same time, needing to “talk” to anyone, even a stranger, I tell one gentleman how I’ve recently relocated from Minneapolis and not far from the shootings at Annunciation. He replies, simply, “I’m so sorry for your loss.” He means it.

That’s fine. But now, as time passes — and please believe me when I tell you this — others with whom I’ve shared your stories not only remain saddened by “your loss” but now know much about, and express admiration for, your well-documented communal and individual courageousness, your inner strength and your fierce determination to hold the powers-that-be accountable to change Minnesota’s and America’s inept gun laws.

Our thoughts from far away remain with you.

Dick Schwartz taught for many years at Southwest High School in Minneapolis.

about the writer

about the writer

Dick Schwartz

More from Commentaries

See More
card image
Leila Navidi/The Minnesota Star Tribune

In government leadership, young people need to be ready to accept the torch, but previous generations can’t slow down their leg, or delay the pass.

card image
card image