Banks: A majesty of a moment for ‘No Kings’

Saturday’s events showed how democracy should be. Of course, they were necessitated by our democracy as it is.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
October 20, 2025 at 9:23PM
Janey Westin, dressed as Lady Liberty, protests alongside thousands of others during a "No Kings" protest on Oct. 18 in Minneapolis. (Alex Kormann/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Opinion editor’s note: Strib Voices publishes a mix of commentary online and in print each day. To contribute, click here.

•••

One of my favorites among photographs from the “No Kings” protests across the country on Saturday was a sign reading: “So bad even the introverts are here.”

It does indeed take a special circumstance to get introverts to rub elbows with a literal mass of humanity, let alone a house party of two dozen people. There were millions of Americans at 2,600 “No Kings” events nationwide. That includes dozens of events in Minnesota, both in cities and smaller communities. Organizers said 100,000 showed up in Minneapolis. Anecdotally from one of northwestern Minnesota’s regional hubs: “Half of the hamlet showed up.”

Counting attendance at large, ungated events is tricky, and people love to quibble over the estimates, but there’s no doubt that Saturday was significant. More so than appears to have been recognized by some who weighed it — including President Donald Trump, who among his gentler comments called the rallies “very small, very ineffective.”

Technically, of course, introverts are no more or no less reflective of the general population than are any subsets of attendees. If they’re not aligned with Trump, they’re likely pretty worried about the adroitly authoritarian tendencies the president is showing during his latest tour in the Oval Office. They’re concerned not just about the immediate effects but about the impact on the country’s future. Just like the younger attendees in the crowds. Just like those who showed up with walkers or in wheelchairs.

And all of it is was peaceful.

That last part was crucial. Saturday’s rallies consisted of Americans exercising their right to peaceably assemble. By golly if it isn’t part of the U.S. Constitution.

The rallies did not consist of Americans hating on our fine country, as U.S. Rep. Tom Emmer, Republican of Minnesota, would have it. Emmer knows better, but he’s busy playing his game.

The rallies didn’t deserve to be dumped on, as top-gun pilot “King Trump” did in an AI-generated video that the president shared as part of his enshittified social-media presence. Trump’s sense of humor — believe it or not, you can detect this at times — is more sophisticated than that of a junior high schooler. But he’s busy playing his game.

As one of my colleagues put it so aptly in our morning meeting on Monday: “What did I do to deserve being in this timeline?”

Former President Barack Obama, who was so measured in most of his language, would occasionally misplace his air of containment and spout off something confrontative. One of the things he said was: “Elections have consequences.” That wasn’t terribly unifying, but it was true. He won two elections, and that meant the electorate had given him the opportunity to pursue his preferred policies.

Last year, Trump won, nonconcurrently, another four years in office. So he gets that chance again too. Enough voters wanted more, or too few were motivated to want less. Trump can see if it still holds true in 2026, during the midterm elections, or in 2028 when he anoints a successor or takes an extraconstitutional flier on a third term.

But he doesn’t get carte blanche in between. Americans are allowed to register their intent even outside of elections. I would say obligated to. And politicians should listen. Especially those who won with 49.8% of the total vote.

“NO Kings … Just Prince” — that was another sign spotted at one of Saturday’s Minnesota rallies. Coincidentally on Saturday evening, I was letting Spotify’s AI “DJ” function serve up music I might be interested in based on my listening history. One of the songs it offered was Prince’s “Guitar,” on which the musical polymath showcases his virtuosity on that instrument. Prince was a performer who like Trump always tested boundaries, but who also showed us that the best performance has substance.

After the song was over, the automated DJ — which is programmed to chime in with banal shoutouts to the artists, asked quizzically: “That was … Prince?!

Obviously, Minnesotans, we have work left to do. On many fronts.

about the writer

about the writer

David Banks

Commentary Editor

David Banks has been involved with various aspects of the opinion pages and their online counterparts since 2005. Before that, he was primarily involved with the editing and production of local coverage. He joined the Star Tribune in 1994.

See Moreicon

More from Columnists

See More
card image
Jessica Griffin /Tribune News Service

Consumers might be tempted by less traditional insurance plans amid soaring premiums and expiring enhanced subsidies. But beware.