RandBall: The Vikings probably overpaid for Adam Thielen, but we can’t be mad

The local angle with Minnesota native Adam Thielen returning to the team is nice. But his fit is what matters most, as Michael Rand writes on today’s 10 things to know.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
August 28, 2025 at 4:24PM
Minnesota Vikings receiver Adam Thielen (19) caught a touchdown pass in the fourth quarter.
Adam Thielen (19) returns to the Vikings after making the team originally as an undrafted free agent. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Our family has recently discovered the benefits of buying specific items secondhand on Facebook Marketplace. Specifically: sports equipment for our three kids who have both rapidly growing bodies and tastes.

After snagging a pair of soccer cleats ($8) for my 5-year-old recently, he had an idea: He, too, wanted to sell things on the site. He gathered up a handful of his least appealing toys and asked if we could try to sell them.

I gently informed him that if he didn’t want his junky plastic heaps, it was unlikely that others would want them. In order to make a transaction, he would have to part with something of actual value.

Let us now bring the same logic to a much larger scale: The Vikings’ recent shopping for a wide receiver. They could have gone simply for a bargain and someone who was cut by another team. Instead, they paid a price for old friend Adam Thielen.

The deal: The Vikings get a conditional seventh-round pick and a fifth-round pick from Carolina plus Thielen, while the Panthers get a sixth and a fourth.

In taking on all of Thielen’s $6.25 million base salary (something they are reportedly working to restructure) and including a fourth-round pick in the deal, you wouldn’t be wrong in saying the Vikings overpaid for a 35-year-old receiver.

But if you need something more specific than a pair of soccer cleats, sometimes you have to pay a premium.

Thielen was exactly what the Vikings needed, and we shouldn’t be hung up on the margins of the deal. Let’s examine why he was the perfect fit at the outset of today’s 10 things to know:

ADVERTISEMENT
  • He’s one of us. I’m listing this first even though it’s far from the most important reason. Still, Thielen’s history with the Vikings and his personal story should not be overlooked. He will be more than motivated to be here, as will his family. Having a trade like this so late in the preseason make sense for a player’s personal life is rare.
    View post on X
    • More importantly, Thielen knows this offense. His last season in Minnesota was 2022, Kevin O’Connell’s first season with the Vikings. Nobody else with Thielen’s skill level would have been as plug-and-play as he is into the offense.
      • Even more important than that: Thielen can still play. He caught 103 passes in 2023 with Carolina. He surged at the end of an injury-marred 2024 season, catching 40 passes for 506 yards and four TDs in the final seven games of the year. That level of production is important for a receiver who just turned 35.
        • Perhaps even more important than all of this: Thielen has a great relationship already with second-year QB J.J. McCarthy and will give him exactly the type of pass catcher he needs. I expect to see a ton of Thielen grabs on third-and-medium and imagine he will be an important target even after Jordan Addison returns from his suspension.
          • La Velle E. Neal III and I talked about the Thielen news and Gophers football expectations ahead of tonight’s season opener on Thursday’s Daily Delivery podcast.
            • But in all honestly, talking and thinking about sports right now still feels strange. We all have jobs to do, and sports remain a pleasant diversion for a lot of us, but Wednesday was the kind of day that sticks with you and makes you realize what is really important. As noted above, we have three kids. They are not all that different in age from those who were most directly affected by the tragedy at Annunciation Church. It was a day that hit very close to home.
              • I tried to articulate some of that at the beginning of Thursday’s podcast.
                • Lynx coach Cheryl Reeve did a great job of expressing her thoughts.
                  View post on X
                  about the writer

                  about the writer

                  Michael Rand

                  Columnist / Reporter

                  Michael Rand is the Minnesota Star Tribune's Digital Sports Senior Writer and host/creator of the Daily Delivery podcast. In 25 years covering Minnesota sports at the Minnesota Star Tribune, he has seen just about everything (except, of course, a Vikings Super Bowl).

                  See Moreicon

                  More from Sports

                  See More
                  card image
                  Jeff McIntosh/The Canadian Press

                  The Flames scored two goals less than three minutes apart early in the third to take control in the Wild’s first regulation loss in nearly a month.

                  card image
                  card image