RandBall: J.J. McCarthy isn’t good enough to be injured this often

Like it or not, there is a sliding scale of tolerance for injuries and off-field issues related to talent and production.

Columnist Icon
The Minnesota Star Tribune
December 22, 2025 at 7:35PM
Vikings quarterback J.J. McCarthy runs off the field during the second quarter against the Giants on Dec. 21 in East Rutherford, N.J. McCarthy suffered a hand injury in the victory. (Elizabeth Flores/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Until 2025, Twins fans had spent the better part of a decade wondering what might happen if Byron Buxton could ever stay healthy for an entire season.

The talent was obvious. The production often followed. But the various ailments were so frustrating.

His greatness is such, though, that it was worth patience and a certain level of bargaining. Even if he could stay healthy for half or two-thirds of the Twins’ games, it would be enough to help them win.

Some players are just like that. J.J. McCarthy is not.

McCarthy, the young Vikings quarterback who won’t be young forever, has now had his career interrupted four times by injuries suffered while playing.

His knee injury in the preseason last year kept him out his entire rookie campaign, which at least kept him from picking up a different injury.

An ankle injury this year cost him five games. Concussion symptoms cost him another. And now he has a hand injury that knocked him out of half of the Vikings’ 16-13 win over the New York Giants on Dec. 21 and could end his season pending more testing.

McCarthy’s last 2½ games were considerably better than his first six, but all of it must be considered. He has played in nine games, true to his self-described alter ego, while being unavailable for 23 others during the last two regular seasons. When he has played, he ranks 31st out of 32 passers in Total QBR.

ADVERTISEMENT

He’s not good enough to be hurt this much — at least not yet. He’s still a frustrating “maybe” after almost two seasons, as Patrick Reusse and I talked about on Monday’s Daily Delivery podcast.

Let’s talk more about that idea, among other topics, in today’s 10 things to know:

  • McCarthy’s numbers Sunday weren’t bad, and they would have been better if not for a Jalen Nailor drop (that led to an interception) and a Jordan Addison drop (that should have been a touchdown).
    • But he also had a 96-yard pick-six wiped off the books by a sketchy defensive penalty. That throw hit the tips of Nailor’s outstretched hands, a high toss that was mostly McCarthy’s fault. And he failed to get the ball out on the catastrophic strip sack and fumble return for a touchdown at the end of the first half, a play that seemingly happened after he was already injured. He was aided greatly by Justin Jefferson’s playmaking. Even before the injury, it felt like a regression from the Dallas game.
      View post on X
      • Max Brosmer was efficient but not spectacular in relief, running much of the same game plan McCarthy had been given. Brosmer, an undrafted rookie, posted a QBR of 69.1 and a passer rating of 90.7, besting McCarthy by more than 30 points in each case.
        • McCarthy’s inconsistent play combined with his consistent injury problems leave the Vikings with no other choice: They have to be looking for, at the very least, upgraded competition at QB going into 2026. It cannot be handed to McCarthy, and it cannot simply be given to him if he doesn’t earn it.
          • Vikings fans, always rational, continue to pine for Joe Burrow.
            • You’ll get more Vikings content on Tuesday’s show with Andrew Krammer’s film review.
              • The Timberwolves got huge contributions from Terrence Shannon Jr. and Mike Conley in their 103-100 win over Milwaukee. The Wolves are 19-10, but it’s still hard to get a read on their ceiling.
                • The Wild have the third-most points in the NHL. Unfortunately, they also have the third-most points in their division behind Dallas and Colorado. And the Avs showed they are in a different class Sunday night.
                  • The Ravens, Chiefs, Commanders and Lions were four of the seven teams with the best Super Bowl odds before the season started. It’s likely that all four will miss the playoffs entirely.
                    • Good news: The Twins are No. 1! The bad news: It’s in ESPN’s Aggrieved Fan Index.
                      about the writer

                      about the writer

                      Michael Rand

                      Columnist / Reporter

                      Michael Rand is the Minnesota Star Tribune's Digital Sports Senior Writer and host/creator of the Daily Delivery podcast. In 25 years covering Minnesota sports at the Minnesota Star Tribune, he has seen just about everything (except, of course, a Vikings Super Bowl).

                      See Moreicon

                      More from Sports

                      See More
                      card image
                      Elizabeth Flores/The Minnesota Star Tribune

                      Like it or not, there is a sliding scale of tolerance for injuries and off-field issues related to talent and production.

                      card image
                      card image