Advertisement

Free-agency haul brings back memories of Kevin Garnett trade

July 3, 2017 at 4:41AM
Timberwolves new forward Jimmy Butler, center, is joined by Timberwolves head coach Tom Thibodeau, left, and General Manager Scott Layden
Photos by Andy Clayton-King • Associated Press (above) and JEFF WHEELER • Star Tribune (below) worth their (KG) Weight? The Timberwolves also made a big rebuilding play in 2007 when they acquired, from left, Theo Ratliff, Al Jefferson, Gerald Green, Ryan Gomes and Sebastian Telfair in the trade of Kevin Garnett. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Advertisement

When evaluating a franchise like the Timberwolves that has missed the playoffs for 13 consecutive seasons, there are plenty of checkpoints along the way at which one can stop and say in retrospect, "That was a reason things haven't worked out."

So indulge me for trying to pinpoint the one critical moment of failure in a 13-year history filled with missteps. But here it is: the trade of Kevin Garnett in the summer of 2007 to the Celtics.

That's not to say the Wolves would have magically avoided their descent into awfulness had they held on to their superstar, who was 31 and coming down the other side of his career. But it was a seismic shift that signified a rebuilding process from which the Wolves have never fully emerged. As long as they had Garnett, they had a chance — if only they could properly build around him, which they had a brutally hard time doing for so much of his career.

The Wolves actually got seven pieces from Boston in that deal, but the three most significant ones were Al Jefferson, Sebastian Telfair and their own 2009 first-round pick, which they had traded to Boston a year earlier in the Wally Szczerbiak/Ricky Davis deal.

Jefferson was a promising but raw young player whose early career had been marred by injuries. Telfair was a 22-year-old point guard who arrived in the NBA with great expectations but had yet to deliver upon them. The draft pick ended up being the 2009 sixth overall pick (which the Wolves used on Jonny Flynn, but enough about that).

Jefferson blossomed into a very good player in Minnesota, but he was never destined to be a star. Telfair had a long but not very distinguished NBA career. Draft picks are always a crapshoot.

In money terms, if Garnett was a dollar bill, the Wolves in exchange received a bunch of loose change — useful, but not even close to adding up to the equivalent value of one player.

If that trade almost a decade ago was the true beginning of the frustrating cycle the Wolves are still in, let's look also for some symmetry and some hope: Perhaps the Jimmy Butler trade was the Garnett trade in reverse, closing the loop and putting Minnesota back on a winning trajectory.

ADVERTISEMENT

The Bulls received, in exchange, a Jefferson equivalent at a different position (Zach LaVine), their own Telfair (Kris Dunn, a point guard young enough to have promise but seasoned enough to have question marks) and the seduction of potential with the No. 7 pick. They got three quarters for a dollar, which sounds good in your piggy bank until it's time to buy something.

There are shades of difference, of course.

Garnett went to Boston, formed a "Big Three" with two other veterans in Paul Pierce and Ray Allen, and immediately won a championship.

Butler arrives in Minnesota as the third member of a budding Big Three along with Karl-Anthony Towns and Andrew Wiggins. Butler is the elder statesman of the group at 27, more than three full years younger than KG when he was traded.

The Timberwolves are not going to win a championship immediately because they are young and Golden State is lapping the field, but the short-term expectation has been elevated to breaking the playoff drought — particularly when combined with the Wolves' free-agent agreements over the weekend.

JEFF WHEELER • jwheeler@startribune.com MINNEAPOLIS - 8/7/07 - At a news conference at Target Center Tuesday afternoon, the Minnesota Timberwolves introduced the five players the team acquired in the trade with the Boston Celtics for Kevin Garnett. IN THIS PHOTO: The gang of five, the newest Timberwolves, from left, Theo Ratliff, Al Jefferson, Gerald Green, Ryan Gomes, and Sebastian Telfair held up their new jerseys at the close of a news conference where they were introduced Tuesday afte
JEFF WHEELER • jwheeler@startribune.com MINNEAPOLIS - 8/7/07 - At a news conference at Target Center Tuesday afternoon, the Minnesota Timberwolves introduced the five players the team acquired in the trade with the Boston Celtics for Kevin Garnett. IN THIS PHOTO: The gang of five, the newest Timberwolves, from left, Theo Ratliff, Al Jefferson, Gerald Green, Ryan Gomes, and Sebastian Telfair held up their new jerseys at the close of a news conference where they were introduced Tuesday afternoon. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

Michael Rand

Columnist / Reporter

Michael Rand is the Minnesota Star Tribune's Digital Sports Senior Writer and host/creator of the Daily Delivery podcast. In 25 years covering Minnesota sports at the Minnesota Star Tribune, he has seen just about everything (except, of course, a Vikings Super Bowl).

See Moreicon

More from Sports

See More
card image
card image
Advertisement