My mom began her career as a reading teacher and later taught fifth-graders at a public school in the Bronx, New York. She shared her love of books with me and with her students. Long after she retired, she continued to read a wide range of genres.
A year ago, at age 91, signs of dementia appeared. Shortly afterward, her reading habit ceased. Focusing on several words on a page became difficult.
On a recent visit, I gave my mom the children’s picture book “Pedal, Balance, Steer: Annie Londonderry, the First Woman to Cycle Around the World,” by Vivian Kirkfield. She opened it immediately while her aide and I watched how engrossed she became. After she finished, she told us exactly about Londonderry’s life. She seemed hooked.
Observing her made me question if picture books would spark her interest in reading again. I work as a journalist, mostly covering health. I looked for studies focusing on dementia and reading children’s books. I found one showing a connection linking frequent reading to a reduced risk of cognitive decline in older adults.
While it’s good to know reading reduces the risk of dementia, that study didn’t answer my questions about children’s books. I decided to ask the experts.
Anecdotes, but no evidence yet
“I haven’t seen any evidence-based studies on this,” said Michal Schnaider Beeri, director of the Herbert and Jacqueline Krieger Klein Alzheimer’s Research Center. “Reading a children’s book is similar to that of music. Just as familiar music can engage Alzheimer’s patients, prompting them to sing, move and enjoy themselves, reading a book can have a similar effect.”
She’s heard anecdotes, but nothing scientifically based. “It’s possible to hear positive responses from clinicians who have witnessed dementia patients sharing examples of how reading plays a vital role for people with dementia,” she explained. “Other clinicians won’t have the same positive results. Reading that children’s book could have sparked a memory for your mom since she spent years reading children’s books.”
Pamela Gray, activities director at White House Healthcare Center (a nursing home in New Jersey), agreed that the children’s book my mom read might have tapped into a memory. “She read children’s books to her students and enjoyed reading children’s books on her own,” she said. “It’s familiar.”