No Statcast data exists to compare his speed with Willie Mays or Mickey Mantle, and it's too early to tell if he can maintain his lead over a full season. So let's just call this a plausible guess: Byron Buxton would be the fastest man ever to lead a league in home runs.
"I don't even know what to say about that," Buxton said, shaking his head as if the notion is absurd. But even if he can't believe it, it's true, at least for a day: Buxton woke up on Thursday as the American League leader, his eight homers just ahead of a half-dozen contenders with seven — and everyone in that pack has played at least five more games than him.
"He's been playing out of his mind right now," teammate Mitch Garver said. "He's changing the way that we play other teams."
Maybe he'll change the way they prepare, too, because Buxton has a secret that few people have noticed: He never hits in public before games.
"I haven't taken batting practice on the field in probably two years," Buxton said of that baseball ritual, the daily 45-minute session of crushing 60-mph lobs from coaches into the third deck of a mostly empty stadium. Buxton doesn't thirst for the confidence boost of tape-measure fly balls, and he prefers to focus on the details of his swing, sometimes going over one point over and over until he feels comfortable.
That's not possible in the six-pitch-and-out constant turnover at home plate.
"You've got guys hitting behind you, so you can't really take your time and do what you want to in the box. I do all my work in the [indoor] cage," Buxton said during, yes, batting practice Tuesday in Cleveland, which he spent working on his defense. "I've got time in there, and if I want to take a minute to figure out what I want to feel with certain pitches or whatever, I can do that. It works for me. I do my best work in the cage."
That he has that freedom is an example of Rocco Baldelli's trust in his players to determine what works best for them.