Economists expected 2014 to be the year in which the global expansion stepped up a gear.
Instead, nearly five years into its recovery from a deep recession, the rich world's economy still looks disappointingly weak. America's GDP grew at an annualized rate of only 0.1 percent in the first quarter. Euro-area growth, at 0.8 percent, was only half the expected pace.
Some of the weakness is temporary (bad weather did not help the United States), and it is not ubiquitous: in Britain and Germany, for example, growth has accelerated, and Japan has put on a brief spurt. Most forecasters still expect the recovery to gain momentum during the year.
But there are reasons to worry. The stagnation in several big European countries, notably Italy and France, is becoming more entrenched. Thanks to a rise in its consumption tax in April, Japan's growth rate is set to tumble, at least temporarily. America's housing rebound has stalled. And across the rich world, yields on long-term government bonds, a barometer of investors' expectations for growth and interest rates, have fallen sharply.
The yield on 10-year Treasuries, at 2.5 percent, is half a percentage point lower than it was at the end of 2013. Given that American expansions tend to be about five years long, the United States could find itself going into the next downturn without having had a decent upturn at all.
What should be done to forestall that outcome? The standard answer is that central banks need to loosen monetary conditions further and keep them loose for longer. In some places that is plainly true. The euro area's weakness has a lot to do with the conservatism of the European Central Bank, which has long resisted the adoption of unconventional measures to loosen monetary policy, even as the region has slipped ever closer to deflation. Thankfully, it has signaled that it will take action at its next meeting in June.
But if loose monetary conditions are a prerequisite for a more vigorous recovery, it is increasingly clear that on their own they are not enough. Indeed, overreliance on central banks may be a big reason behind the present sluggishness. In recent years, monetary policy has been the rich world's main, and often only, tool to support growth.
A hollow pledge
Fiscal policy has worked in the opposite direction: virtually all rich-world governments have been cutting their deficits, often at a rapid clip. Few have shown much appetite for the ambitious supply-side reforms that might raise productivity and induce firms to invest. Free-trade deals languish. The much-promised deepening of Europe's single market, whether in digital commerce or services, remains a hollow pledge.