As questions go, this one troubles me a lot: Do we love our homes more than we should? It bothers me because I have been a homeownership nut my entire adult life.
That's not hyperbole.
I bought my first, a rooming house in Boston's South End, at age 23. I have been buying and fixing up houses ever since. A dozen in all.
As investments, my houses have ranged from neutral to fantastic. But the real deal was about owning a home. Eventually without a mortgage.
So I'm not sure I qualify as an objective observer on this topic. In my heart, I am a homeowner.
But something jumped out when I did the data grinding for a recent update of the wealth scoreboard, which details our collective net worth by age group. For most Americans, homeownership is the primary source of net worth. Without it, our net worth is small. With it, our net worth is larger and better.
You can get a sense of this by examining the distribution of net worth with and without home equity for households in the age 55 to 59 age range — those on the runway to retirement.
As you would expect, home equity is a small part of net worth for the top 1%. With an all-inclusive net worth of at least $17.5 million, their net worth less home equity is $16.3 million. Only 6.9% of their net worth is in home equity. The remainder is in assets that earn returns.