Name 2016 votes (percent) Years on ballot
Ken Griffey Jr. 437 (99.3) 1
Mike Piazza 365 (83.0) 4
Jeff Bagwell 315 (71.6) 6
Tim Raines 307 (69.8) 9
Trevor Hoffman 296 (67.3) 1
Curt Schilling 230 (52.3) 4
Roger Clemens 199 (45.2) 4
Barry Bonds 195 (44.3) 4
Edgar Martinez 191 (43.4) 7
Mike Mussina 189 (43.0) 3
Alan Trammell 180 (40.9) 15
Lee Smith 150 (34.1) 14
Fred McGriff 92 (20.9) 9
Jeff Kent 73 (16.6) 3
Larry Walker 68 (15.5) 6
Mark McGwire 54 (12.3) 10
Gary Sheffield 51 (11.6) 2
Billy Wagner 46 (10.5) 1
Sammy Sosa 31 (7.0) 4
Jim Edmonds 11 (2.5) 1
Nomar Garciaparra 8 (1.8) 2
Mike Sweeney 3 (0.7) 1
David Eckstein 2 (0.5) 1
Jason Kendall 2 (0.5) 1
Garret Anderson 1 (0.2) 1
Brad Ausmus 0 1
Luis Castillo 0 1
Troy Glaus 0 1
Mark Grudzielanek 0 1
Mike Hampton 0 1
Mike Lowell 0 1
Randy Winn 0 1