One of the more humbling and rewarding parts about being a columnist is the connection I have with you.
I've shared with you my thoughts on everything from free speech on college campuses to pickleball cliques, while also revealing my own personal journeys and hardships. On some days, you write me words of encouragement. Other days, you tell me when I get it wrong.
Tom Horner was one of several readers who thought I missed the mark on a column I wrote about a new full-time Taylor Swift beat reporting gig — the only one of its kind in the nation — going to a man. I said the reporter hired by the newspaper chain Gannett was more than qualified, but the decision still stung given how much Swift writes for and about girls and women.
Tom, a public relations veteran and former journalist who once ran for governor, said newsrooms need to become more diverse. But he balked at the idea that one's gender should count against anyone for landing a specific beat.
"If a reporter with shared identity isn't available to cover a newsmaker, should the story be ignored?" he wrote. "As absurd as that seems, it is exactly what is happening in the world of art with the debate over cultural appropriation. In the eyes of many, an artist — painter, writer, performer or other artist — who does not have a shared identity or experience with the subject too often becomes the target of such vitriol that useful perspectives now are left out of the discussions."
I think that's fair criticism. I also heard from Brian Berube, a 67-year-old Edina man who grew up in poor, rural Missouri and later worked in such male-dominated professions as firefighting and college athletics. He said I won him over with a line in which I asked whether a trust-fund kid from Manhattan would be the logical pick for a full-time poverty reporter based in Appalachia.
"Couldn't argue with anything you said," he told me. "I grew up third-world poor — it's hard for me to not get choked up about it. I don't know if a trust-fund kid from Manhattan or Wayzata can truly get it."
A kinship over head lice