Winter fishing in Minnesota: Ice is nice

Winter angling doesn't require lots of gear, and those who head out on the ice often have success catching fish.

December 9, 2009 at 12:40PM
A tripped tip-up — a sort of automatic bite detector — is signified by a red flag popping up, in a demonstration exhibit at the ice fishing show overseen by a poster depicting a happy winter angler.
A tripped tip-up — a sort of automatic bite detector — is signified by a red flag popping up, in a demonstration exhibit at the ice fishing show overseen by a poster depicting a happy winter angler. (Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Ice fishing has come of age in Minnesota, as anyone who attended the St. Paul Ice Fishing and Winter Sports Show at RiverCentre last weekend can attest. Aisles were packed and equipment -- everything from fish-bite indicators priced at a few bucks to mobile fish houses costing many thousands -- seemed to be selling.

Among reasons:

• While ice fishing can cost a lot of money, depending on equipment purchased, it doesn't have to. No boat is needed. And the gear itself, from rods and reels to lines and lures, generally is less expensive than the equipment anglers use in summer.

• Winter anglers often are successful. Panfish particularly can be suckers for cold-weather tear-drop jigs and waxworms or other bait. Also, on the right lake at the right time, particularly in early season, walleyes and northerns are regularly winched through the ice.

• Ice fishing can be enjoyed alone or, if your fish house is big enough, with as many as a dozen others.

• Getting started is easy. You need an auger. Also a rod and reel (some winter anglers use jig sticks, which don't require reels), a few bobbers and a dozen or so small jigs. Most everything else is optional.

When to fish

Answer: When ice is safe.

That said, four anglers were spotted a few days ago on South Center Lake near Chisago, fishing over what could only be 2 or perhaps 3 inches of ice, with open water nearby.

Which is a fun story if everyone makes it to shore.

Anglers on the ice at the earliest safe time have the right idea, however.

Panfish and walleyes are usually at their hungriest during the first weeks of ice fishing, when underwater lake and river vegetation dies, forcing the small critters living there to head for shallower water.

Hoping to munch on these tiny prey, panfish, walleyes and northerns follow.

As winter continues, most Minnesota fish, with the exception perhaps of lake trout, become less active and eat less frequently.

They can still be caught, but usually not as often as in early season -- thus the emphasis on being on the water as soon as possible after safe ice forms.

But so far, winter isn't unfolding as ice anglers would like. Ideally, November would have been much colder than it was, allowing lake and river ice to form before the first heavy snows arrived.

Instead, November was warm and ice hasn't formed very solidly in most parts of the state. Also, as you read this, it's probably snowing -- a bad combination that can significantly slow development of uniformly sturdy ice.

Still, Scott Edwards of Cyrus Resort on Lake of the Woods said at the Ice Fishing show last weekend that winter angling on the big lake won't be far off, assuming the low temperatures the region has experienced in recent days continue.

Where to fish

The Twin Cities area is loaded with first-class winter-fishing lakes and rivers. Minnetonka and Waconia are great. Also, White Bear, Bald Eagle, Chisago, Big Marine and the St. Croix River, to name a few.

Local bait shops near these waters are a good source of information. So are specialty retailers such as Gander Mountain, Cabela's, Dick's, Joe's and Thorne Bros.

On some of these lakes and rivers, rental fish houses are available, as they are up north, on Mille Lacs, Leech, Winnibigoshish, Upper Red and Lake of the Woods, to name a few.

(Find rental outfits by searching the Internet using as key words the lake name and "rental fish houses.")

More exotic trips also are possible. Dog sled outings into the Boundary Waters Canoe Area Wilderness for a day (or days) of lake trout fishing aren't soon forgotten. (Trout lakes can also be reached by skiing cross-country.) And Devils Lake in North Dakota usually provides memorable outings for perch.

The (not so) optional stuff

Ice fishing can be done on the cheap. But anyone who takes the sport even halfway seriously soon adds at least some of the following to his or her arsenal.

• Depth finder/fish locator: Spend an afternoon or evening with a winter-fishing friend who uses a Vexilar, MarCum or other specialized depth finder and you'll soon be ordering one yourself.

Not only do these gizmos help catch fish, they're entertaining in ways your fishing partners only imagine themselves to be. With one of these units you can watch your jig drop to the bottom of a lake and see also a fish approach the lure, allowing you to set the hook at just the right time.

• Portable shelter: Clam is a big name here. So is Eskimo. And Frabill. And Canvas Craft in the Twin Cities is an innovator of portable shelters on trailers that can also tote four-wheelers.

• Hard-sided portable shelters: Built on wheels, these homes-away-from-home are a big hit among serious and even quasi-serious winter anglers. Easily moved from location to location, they nonetheless are well insulated and heated, and often come with stoves, ovens, beds and even bathrooms.

Dennis Anderson • danderson@startribune.com

Tia Sumption of Scandia and her son, James, 4, tried their luck "ice fishing'' for trout at the St. Paul Ice Fishing and Winter Sports Show, held last weekend at RiverCentre. A trout pond was below, and the mother and son angling combination tried to entice a fish to bite.
Tia Sumption of Scandia and her son, James, 4, tried their luck “ice fishing’’ for trout at the St. Paul Ice Fishing and Winter Sports Show, held last weekend at RiverCentre. A trout pond was below, and the mother and son angling combination tried to entice a fish to bite. (Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Minnesota's Dave Genz is Mr. Ice Fishing, having promoted the sport long before it was cool. Genz held a rapt audience Sunday at the Ice Fishing show, telling listeners how they, too, could catch fish in winter.
Minnesota’s Dave Genz is Mr. Ice Fishing, having promoted the sport long before it was cool. Genz held a rapt audience Sunday at the Ice Fishing show, telling listeners how they, too, could catch fish in winter. (Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Tired of that four-wheeler getting stuck in the snow? Machines rigged with tracks avoid that problem in winter.
Tired of that four-wheeler getting stuck in the snow? Machines rigged with tracks avoid that problem in winter. (Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
Tom Auger of Lake Elmo sat in the stillness on the St. Croix River, Dec. 18, 2007.
Tom Auger of Lake Elmo sat in the stillness on the St. Croix River, Dec. 18, 2007. (Star Tribune/The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

Dennis Anderson

Columnist

Outdoors columnist Dennis Anderson joined the Star Tribune in 1993 after serving in the same position at the St. Paul Pioneer Press for 13 years. His column topics vary widely, and include canoeing, fishing, hunting, adventure travel and conservation of the environment.

See Moreicon

More from No Section

See More
FILE -- A rent deposit slot at an apartment complex in Tucker, Ga., on July 21, 2020. As an eviction crisis has seemed increasingly likely this summer, everyone in the housing market has made the same plea to Washington: Send money — lots of it — that would keep renters in their homes and landlords afloat. (Melissa Golden/The New York Times) ORG XMIT: XNYT58
Melissa Golden/The New York Times

It’s too soon to tell how much the immigration crackdown is to blame.