The news that Stephen Colbert will be taking over the "Late Show" desk from David Letterman led Rush Limbaugh, noted comedy expert, to describe this as a sign that "CBS has declared war on the heartland of America" and that "no longer is comedy going to be a covert assault on traditional American values, conservatives — now it's just going to be wide out in the open. What this hire means is a redefinition of what is funny and a redefinition of what is comedy."
Actually, I think it's the opposite. By taking Stephen Colbert to broadcast and shutting down "Stephen Colbert" (as the Wall Street Journal reports), CBS has shifted the playing field in the opposite direction. The kind of comedy that pushes the edge, takes on sacred cows and plays against accepted values was "Stephen Colbert" to a T. But he's just been iced. "Stephen Colbert" of Comedy Central's "The Colbert Report" was a vital satirical force. Stephen Colbert will be a late-night host.
It's a nice professional step, but satire just took a big hit.
We know a great deal about the character Stephen Colbert: pompous right-wing blowhard, lover of eagles and hater of bears, author of "I Am America (And So Can You!)."
About Stephen Colbert, we know some things. He is Catholic, he has a lovely singing voice and he lives with his family in New Jersey. He has deft comic timing and is a gifted interviewer.
But I think "Stephen Colbert" was his better half. As the New York Times pointed out in 2012, when he and his super PAC were rampaging about the country, the interaction of the Real World, in all its sublime ridiculousness, with the satirical world of "Stephen Colbert" had begun to produce something else. Mr. Hyde was gaining power. Hyde had his own super PAC, with something like 30,000 donors.
The creation was starting to take on a life of its own, throwing political rallies and attracting live donors. It was endlessly fascinating — constant proof that the world was even more absurd than you thought and that perhaps parody had no limit. "Stephen Colbert" was real and fake at the same time. The show was one of the few places — I can count them on one hand, and one of the fingers is "Borat" — where you could be sure that whatever was happening was satire. Now the Onion has to take up the slack. The clarity of tone was critical and allowed Colbert to push the debate in ways that even Jon Stewart couldn't.
With Colbert gone, there will be a hole in the late-night lineup. Stewart remains to point out how ridiculous the news is, but as my colleague Erik Wemple has noted, Stewart is in some ways just a fantastic media critic. Colbert got to push it further.
