She's in! She's given up the private jet to schlep across America (albeit being driven by the Secret Service) and stroll, incognito, into Chipotle. Herewith, two myths about Hillary Clinton and two challenges for her on the campaign trail:
Myth No. 1: She needs someone to run against her to help toughen her up during the primary season.
Ha! Do you know of any companies with monopoly power that urge competitors to come in and challenge their dominance? Didn't think so. If anyone understands the painful difference between a seemingly clear path to the nomination (Clinton 2008) and an actually clear path (Clinton 2016), it's her.
The downside of having an even quasi-serious, Democratic challenger is that it would pull Clinton to the left. That may be where Elizabeth Warren & Co. want her, but it's not where Clinton wants to be in a general-election contest. Consider the predicament of Jeb Bush, who has said he is willing to lose the primaries (except not actually lose lose) to win the general. Think he'd trade places with Clinton?
The theoretical upside of having a challenger is that it would provide a sparring partner to prepare her for the general election matchup and deflect some attention from what David Corn of Mother Jones calls the "around-the-clock Hillary Bashathon."
If you think Clinton's problem is that she may not be adequately battle-scarred, you have forgotten the 1990s or didn't live through them. Not tough enough is not her problem. As to the Bashathon, you think Republicans will ease up on her if they've got Martin O'Malley to kick around?
Myth No. 2: It's all about that base.
Not exactly. Campaign consultants debate whether the route to the presidency is to motivate (or expand) the base or to win over the vanishing pool of swing voters. When it comes to Clinton, the undecided pool is even teensier than usual: The percentage of voters with no opinion about Clinton — 4 percent in the latest Washington Post poll — is even smaller than those with a positive view of Congress.
Meanwhile, the hardest core of the Democratic base will probably never be over the moon about Clinton. As she applies policy prescriptions to the campaign theme that "the deck is still stacked in favor of those at the top," I suspect it will be insufficient to mollify the leftiest elements of the Democratic base.
And yet, I also suspect that they, and other traditional Democrats, will turn out for Clinton in November 2016 — if not from overflowing enthusiasm, than out of fear of her Republican opponent. Consider the dire warnings about aggrieved Clinton supporters staying home in the 2008 general election. Women favored Barack Obama over John McCain by 57 percent to 43 percent.