War in Gaza

January 5, 2009 at 2:41PM

WAR IN GAZA

Israeli action will make things worse

There is great grief around the globe for the people in Gaza, but there should be a genuine fear for the safety of Israeli citizens as well. As a Palestinian with Israeli citizenship, I have many friends and family members who are in range of Hamas rockets in the south and of Hezbollah rockets in the north.

While at first glance the Israeli actions against Hamas in Gaza may seem like a legitimate response to rocket fire, in the long run, the actions of the Israeli government have put more Israeli and Palestinian lives in jeopardy and may possibly have ruined the hopes of ever reaching a two-state solution.

It's important to think about the events of last week not only in the present but also in the context of the past and future. A poll from Israel last week indicated only 39 percent of respondents thought that the massive attacks against Hamas in Gaza would lead to an end of rocket fire. Perhaps this is because the Israeli government had already found a way to practically end rocket fire before abandoning it for belligerency.

During the Egyptian-brokered cease-fire, Hamas rocket fire from Gaza dropped dramatically. However, instead of nurturing what could have been the beginning of a much longer cease-fire, the Israeli government took a calculated step on Nov. 4 by killing four Hamas members it accused of smuggling weapons. Immediately afterward Hamas responded by sending rockets, and Israel tightened its siege on Gaza.

Every step taken by the Israeli Cabinet is thought about carefully. They hope now, with this war that they brought on, to "change the equation" and break the stalemate in the peace process that has existed since Hamas was elected in 2006. But does this really change the equation?

Even if the entire leadership of Hamas, a designated terror organization, is wiped out by Israeli raids, does that in any way change the rejectionist sentiment among the population that elected it? Of course not. In fact, it will probably make the situation worse.

Hamas is not merely an organization, it is a movement, and more and more people in the Arab and Muslim world grow sympathetic each time it is attacked.

YOUSEF MUNAYYER, AMERICAN-ARAB ANTI-DISCRIMINATION COMMITTEE, WASHINGTON

about the writer

about the writer

More from Commentaries

See More

Opinion: When seen, children shine

card image
card image