Vikings tumble in NFL rankings based on team's under-25 players

August 8, 2019 at 1:17AM
Buffalo Bills quarterback Josh Allen (17) fumbled the football after being hit by Minnesota Vikings defensive back Harrison Smith (22) in the third quarter, Bills recovered the ball at US Bank Stadium Sunday September 23, 2018 in Minneapolis, MN. ] JERRY HOLT • jerry.holt@startribune.com
Vikings safety Harrison Smith, above sacking Bills quarterback Josh Allen, is 30 but still in his prime. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Football Outsiders recently published its annual rankings of all 32 NFL teams based on the overall talent of players under 25 years old on their rosters.

Two numbers stood out immediately: 28 and 8 — the first being the Vikings' ranking this season and the second being their ranking just a year ago, a drop of 20 spots.

The methodology takes into account a variety of factors, including number of snaps played and relative value of contracts for players under 25 who are expected to contribute in 2019.

When you distill all the numbers, though, what you're left with is this: an interesting and telling snapshot of exactly where the Vikings stand.

• Teams high on the list, for instance, tend to be ascending teams who haven't necessarily proven much yet. They are loaded with young talent because they have had high draft picks — the result of underachieving seasons and/or roster rebuilds that included deals high on potential.

The Browns, for instance, top this year's list. The Bills, Jets and Giants are also in the top seven.

• Teams low on the list, by contrast, tend to have older rosters that are built to win now. The Eagles and Patriots are No. 32 and No. 31, respectively. They met in the Super Bowl two years ago, the Patriots won last year, and it would hardly be shocking if one or both made it this season.

Lacking players under 25 doesn't necessarily mean a roster is old. Rather it means that in the case of a good roster, at least, there are a lot of players in their prime who possibly have played together for a while.

ADVERTISEMENT

That sounds a lot like the Vikings, particularly on defense. And on offense? Stefon Diggs no longer qualifies as under 25, but that doesn't mean he's suddenly lost a step even if he makes the Vikings go down in the rankings.

• For further evidence of a short-term edge gained by more veteran teams: Football Outsiders also tracks average roster age, taking into account playing time for a more accurate measure, and has found that seven of the last eight Super Bowl winners had rosters that were among the 10 oldest in the league.

The Patriots had the NFL's oldest roster last year when they won the Super Bowl, and Football Outsiders notes that they routinely chart very low in the under 25 talent rankings.

• That said, the Vikings' tumble from No. 8 to 28 does likely reflect a need to eventually replenish their talent pool. Contributions from young offensive linemen Brian O'Neill and Garrett Bradbury and a strong rebound season from 2018 first-round cornerback Mike Hughes are important not just for 2019 but for the long-term success of the Vikings.

After all, not everyone can be the Patriots — a team that has a knack for maximizing value from young veterans and knowing when to move on. NFL players get expensive as they get older, and gauging when their play will drop off is tricky.

By Football Outsiders' measure, the Vikings had the NFL's eighth-oldest defense last season. A lot of that core is still intact, while a lot of their key offensive players are another year older as well. That's either a positive or a negative, depending on how you look at it.

The Vikings' window is still open, but there's no guarantee that will mean success in 2019 — nor does it mean the window will stay open much longer.

Rookie center Garrett Bradbury prepared to snap the ball to quarterback Kirk Cousins during the first day of training for Vikings rookies at TCO Performance Center Tuesday July, 23 2019 in Eagan, MN.] Jerry Holt • Jerry.holt@startribune.com
Rookie center Garrett Bradbury of the Vikings is one of the top young players on a team ranked No. 28 by Football Outsiders based on the overall talent of players under 25 on its roster. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)
about the writer

about the writer

Michael Rand

Columnist / Reporter

Michael Rand is the Minnesota Star Tribune's Digital Sports Senior Writer and host/creator of the Daily Delivery podcast. In 25 years covering Minnesota sports at the Minnesota Star Tribune, he has seen just about everything (except, of course, a Vikings Super Bowl).

See Moreicon

More from Sports

See More
card image
Jeff Wheeler/The Minnesota Star Tribune

Provencher had a time of 1 minute, 15.01 seconds to beat two-time defending state champion Taylor Voigt of Hill-Murray for the individual title.

card image
card image