Two speakers: Each has special features

Q I read your recent column recommending the $249 Acculine A1 bookshelf speakers. How do they compare to the $296 Axiom Audio M2 v2 speakers you also recommend?

JIM BUKOWSKI, Pittsburgh, PA

A I prefer to provide firm answers such as when I called HD DVD the clear choice over Blu-ray, but this one is not so easy for me. Both are excellent speakers, but I would say they perform differently rather than one being better than the other. There are brand differences beyond sound quality.

What makes the Acculines special is their leaf tweeters, typically found only in very expensive, exotic speakers. These tweeters must be heard to be appreciated, as they render sound so transparently and with so much detail that I liken it to a sonic version of the visual difference between HDTV and analog TV. I imagine a lot of new owners will turn their heads in disbelief as they hear sounds in their recordings they never knew existed.

In comparison, the Axiom M2 has a fuller midrange and an ever-so-slightly more balanced sound from top to bottom. They don't impress the way the Acculine leaf tweeters do, but the M2s leave you satisfied and never wanting for more. Axiom has been designing great speakers for a long time, and this refinement and balance is a testament to the skill and experience of Ian Colquhoun, Axiom's founder and chief designer.

Finish is an important consideration for many buyers. Acculines are available in only basic black. Axiom has 16 exterior finishes and six grill cloth designs, allowing you to design your speakers at the website's Custom Shop.

Things get interesting when you move beyond a pair of bookshelf speakers and into a whole system. To show Acculine's extreme value equation, we will build two Acculine 5.1 channel systems.

The Acculine A1s are $249 per pair with two pairs required, one for mains and one for surrounds. This comes to $498. The A-2 Center Channel is $179 and the Acculine ASub is $289. This gets you a top-performing home theater speaker system for only $966.

The second Acculine system mimics the one above, but uses Acculine A3 towers as main speakers. The A3s are $499 per pair, a $250 difference which brings the total to $1216. This is incredible for a high-quality system using tower speakers.

Moving to Axiom, their M2-based Epic Midi home theater is $1338.55, the Epic 50 system using tower speakers is $1921.85. That's more than the Acculine systems, but you get Axiom's incredible QS surround speakers, which radiate in four directions for spectacular surround effects. As a full-line manufacturer, Axiom has main speakers, surround speakers, center channels, in-wall and outdoor speakers and subwoofers. With Axiom you can build a system for any room, while Acculine's smaller product line limits their capabilities somewhat.

Check out Axiom's offerings at www.axiomaudio.com and the Acculine speakers at exclusive distributor the Audio Insider at www.theaudioinsider.com. Whichever way you go, you won't go wrong. And both companies have 30-day money-back satisfaction guarantees.

Submit questions and read past columns at www.soundadviceblog.com.