Kyle Gibson made 18 starts before the All-Star Game. You could eliminate the thumb on one hand and count the clunkers.
There was a run of six starts before the midsummer break where Gibson's effort rated from good to excellent. He had pitched 113⅔ innings and was headed for his first 200-inning season.
The Twins decided to come out of the All-Star respite with Erv Santana and Tommy Milone as the first two starters. This gave Gibson nine days between starts and it seemed like a wise move to give his right arm a chance to freshen up.
It didn't turn out that way.
Throw out a bad first start in Detroit and Gibson had 17 starts from April 15 to July 12 with these numbers: 8-5 with a 2.45 ERA, and 94 hits in 110 innings for a .232 opponent batting average.
Then, in his first six starts after the nine-day refresher, Gibson was 0-3 with a 7.91 ERA, and 42 hits in 33 innings for a .309 opponent average. The last of those was Aug. 17 at Yankee Stadium, when the Twins gave Gibson a 6-2 lead after 4½ innings and he couldn't hold it.
This was a trend that the Twins couldn't afford to see continue. Phil Hughes had gone on the disabled list because of a bad back Aug. 13. Santana was in the midst of a six-game stretch (still ongoing) in which he is 0-4 with a 9.20 ERA.
The rest of the rotation was Milone, Mike Pelfrey and rookie Tyler Duffey. If Gibson remained in the tank, the Twins had no one that any other playoff contender would consider to be a top-three starter.