GLENDALE, ARIZ. – Where others see talent, Byron Buxton notices flaws. Where outsiders judge him the best, Buxton seeks improvement. Where scouts marvel at the breadth of his ability, Buxton is frustrated that it's not deeper.
"I see the pitches I didn't hit, the [fly] balls I didn't get to. Bad jumps, getting fooled by pitches, bad throws," said Buxton, grading himself far more harshly than the observers who named him the top prospect in minor league baseball. So what does he plan to improve upon this offseason? "I'd say everything. I can be better at everything."
With that sort of mentality showing in Buxton, the Twins decided to send him to suburban Phoenix for six weeks, offering him a spot in the Arizona Fall League that rarely goes to position players with only one full season behind them. Buxton has less experience than the other two Twins hitters joining him in Arizona — Eddie Rosario and Max Kepler, each of whom has been in the Twins system for four years — but the 19-year-old gets most of the attention.
"He's adapted to everything we've put in front of him, so OK, here's another big challenge for you," Twins General Manager Terry Ryan said of the team's top draft pick from 2012. "These pitchers know how to pitch a little bit more than what [Buxton has] seen so far. They're experienced. Let's see how you deal with that."
One hang-up: a strained shoulder
The Twins didn't get to see as much as they had hoped; Buxton strained his right shoulder on a check swing just a week after arriving in Glendale — "First time in my life I've ever been in the trainer's room," he said — then "tweaked" the injury shortly after his return while sliding head-first into second base on a successful steal attempt, causing the Twins to end his fall league experience early. It meant Buxton played in only 12 games, but the Twins said they saw the same thing from Buxton that he has done at every stop: failure initially, then a gradual and noticeable mastery of his surroundings.
Buxton is like a sponge, said Mike Radcliff, Twins vice president for player personnel. "He looks like he's in pretty deep right at first, but he starts soaking in the pitching, getting used to what they're doing, taking good at-bats," Radcliff said. "And pretty soon, he's passed them."
The Twins would have liked to see how far Buxton would have gotten in Arizona, where he was batting leadoff or third for the Glendale Desert Dogs, with another dozen games or so of seeing headed-for-the-majors pitching. He batted just .212, albeit with three home runs, but was showing signs of improvement, especially in his patience at the plate; he virtually always takes the first pitch of an at-bat, to gauge the pitching he's facing.. "He makes good adjustments, that's what you like to see," Radcliff said.
And his slow start at the plate didn't affect the rest of his game. Buxton has made a specialty of going from first to third in record time on a hit, and his defense delights Desert Dogs manager Jeff Smith, who likely will coach Buxton at Class AA New Britain next summer. "One thing I've noticed is how many balls he's cut off in the outfield. The gaps are tiny with him out there — he's holding line drives to singles," Smith said. "You do that, you set up so many double plays for your defense."