Tip-credit argument is nonsense in minimum-wage debate

Ignore the restaurant industry's recycled arguments.

February 22, 2014 at 1:05AM
A dining check on a saucer with change from a meal payment.
A dining check on a saucer with change from a meal payment. (The Minnesota Star Tribune)

Although neither of the minimum-wage bills pending in the Minnesota House and Senate has a provision that allows servers to be paid less than the minimum wage, you would never know it from restaurant industry exhortations. The Feb. 1 Business section commentary, "In the push for higher pay, don't forget tips," needs correcting.

Minnesota law bars the practice of paying servers less than the minimum wage of $7.25 an hour, because labor standards have been higher here since 1986. Surrounding states have no such prohibition. Wisconsin pays $2.33, Iowa $4.35, North Dakota $4.86 and South Dakota $2.13.

In his commentary, a Minneapolis restaurant owner insisted that paying the minimum to wait staff "artificially puts downward pressure on kitchen wages" — an argument that gets recycled every year but is never supported by the facts. The notion is contradicted by wage data from surrounding states. For example, that a Wisconsin waitress earns $2.33 an hour, but kitchen workers still earn nearly $1 an hour less than Minnesota workers.

Minnesota legislators should understand that the real "artificial pressure" is coming from a handful of well-heeled lobbyists hired to exploit their advantages, lower our expectations and drop the higher standards that define our differences. Minnesotans value a workforce that is always at or near the top of every measure of labor force excellence. Let's keep it that way.

Kris Jacobs is executive director of Jobs Now Coalition.

about the writer

about the writer

Kris Jacobs

More from Commentaries

See More
card image
Carlos Gonzalez/The Minnesota Star Tribune

It seems like we’re now heading in the right direction under the leadership of White House border czar Tom Homan.

Opinion | What happens after our shock fades?

card image
card image